-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA512 On 6/14/12 12:09 PM, Robert J. Hansen wrote: > > So, let's move this discussion about proprietary programs (GPGShell) > into a direction that's useful to FOSS programs. What is it about > GPGShell that you really like? What makes it superior to the FOSS > alternatives? How can the FOSS alternatives be made superior to > GPGShell? Inquiring minds very much want to know. :)
Here is one immediate issue. It seems that I cannot install GnuPGShell at all, as my GnuPG is 1.4.12, and GnuPGShell does not seem to recognize it. I guess I can install GPG4win on my home computer and see if that works. Perhaps I am an exception, but I use GnuPG most often when composing webmail. Which means I type the email in a browser window or in a text file, copy the text to memory, perform the signatures/encryption on the clipboard, and paste the results into the browser window. On the other hand, being somewhat geeky, I want the ability to do most anything that the command line can do when needed. When I started looking at GUIs, the options for Windows were GPGShell, WinPT, and GPA. Here are some things I like about GPGShell which were either lacking, or less robust in the others. 1) It has a bundled program, Copy2USB, which can take an existing GnuPG install and copy the needed files and settings to a USB stick, making for a portable installation. 2) It has a tray program, GPGTray, from which I can launch the key manager, encrypt/decrypt/sign/import the clipboard, launch a app that allows me to drag files onto a taskbar to encrypt/decrypt/sign. 3) It has many options for key management "right clickable" in the key management GUI (sign, lsign, clean, minimize, check UID, update from keyserver, export to clipboard, etc.), yet can launch the command-line edit allowing for complete control in a DOS-window 4) It allows for a central place to update gpg.conf without having to launch text editors, and while most of the main options are either checkboxes or radioboxes, there is a free- form area where any option (such as "expert" or "bzip2-compress- level") can be added 5) It does not require registry settings to use (see #1) which allows for a truly portable installation 6) It makes navigating GnuPG's configurations easier (at least for 1.4.x) so that the program files are easily placed on one drive and the certificates/keyrings on another without issue. When I tried WinPT and GPA, none of them had the combination of robustness, completeness, and ease-of-use that GPGShell demonstrated, which is why I have stayed with it for the time being. Perhaps GnuPGShell has all of these properties as well, I guess I can try GnuPG 2.0.x and see, but until such time as a portable installation of GnuPG 2.0.x for Windows exists, I'll likely stay with the working combination of 1.4.12 + GPGShell. More information can be found here: <http://www.jumaros.de/rsoft/faq.html> I hope that helps, Avi -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1.4.12 (MingW32) - GPGshell v3.78 Comment: Most recent key: Click show in box @ http://is.gd/4xJrs iL4EAREKAGYFAk/ahXBfGGh0dHA6Ly9rZXlzZXJ2ZXIudWJ1bnR1LmNvbS9wa3Mv bG9va3VwP29wPWdldCZoYXNoPW9uJmZpbmdlcnByaW50PW9uJnNlYXJjaD0weDBE NjJCMDE5RjgwRTI5RjkACgkQDWKwGfgOKflV8QD/QSUtLqFFfOR7uiEtNt+/yvkN hAW22wEk+DKqq0Ld+9gBAJXylD704ILyqtR7BJtdY+7GxHXCcvi+gXxrIQcF679j =C8+C -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- ---- User:Avraham pub 3072D/F80E29F9 1/30/2009 Avi (Wikimedia-related key) <avi.w...@gmail.com> Primary key fingerprint: 167C 063F 7981 A1F6 71EC ABAA 0D62 B019 F80E 29F9 _______________________________________________ Gnupg-users mailing list Gnupg-users@gnupg.org http://lists.gnupg.org/mailman/listinfo/gnupg-users
