Ah, one other thing:

On Fri, Oct 17, 2025 at 4:27 PM D. Ben Knoble <[email protected]> wrote:
> >
> > Do you have some duplicated AP connection and nm will not stop?
> >
> > Your log shows successive de/re-authentication with different APs, e.g. 
> > first
> > with 70:58:a4:d2:14:21 and then within seconds:
> >
> > disconnect from AP 70:58:a4:d2:14:21 for new auth to 70:58:a4:d2:14:29
>
> Right, I noticed this too! I have a main router downstairs and an extender
> upstairs in the same room as the device in question. As I explained over on my
> blog:
>
> I saved some logs with
>
> { echo count from to;
>   grep 'disconnect from AP' /var/log/messages |
>     grep -o '\([[:xdigit:]][[:xdigit:]]:\?\)\{6\}' | paste - - |
>     sort | uniq -c; } | column -t
>
> which gave for example
>
> count  from               to
> 3      <prefix>:2f:a9:51  <prefix>:2f:a9:59
> 22     <prefix>:2f:a9:51  <prefix>:d2:14:29
> 1      <prefix>:d2:14:21  <prefix>:2f:a9:59
> 2      <prefix>:d2:14:21  <prefix>:d2:14:29
>
> As far as I can tell, the (masked) <prefix> there matches the output from
> another connected device when checking the router with arp -a:
>
> gr6exx0c-a940.lan (192.168.2.1) at <prefix>:2f:a9:40 on en0 ifscope [ethernet]
>
> And my (Google Fiber) management app says
>
> - the router has a MAC of <prefix>:2f:a9:41
> - the extender (MoCA) has a MAC of <prefix>:d2:14:10
>
> So clearly something is going on here, and the NetworkManager is having 
> trouble
> deciding which connection to use? But I'm not sure what the deal is with all
> those MACs that end in different digits.
>
> My other devices don't seem to have a problem, but I haven't looked (and am 
> not
> sure how to look) to see if there are repeatedly re-authenticating like this.
>
> As I'll mention below, but so as not to bury the lede: iwd is now installed 
> and
> configured (with wpa_supplicant gone), but I'm still seeing this behavior. It
> might now even be more prevalent (occurring every minute?).
>
> Thoughts?

Now with iwd, the reconnect happening every minute is at least to the
same MAC (always <prefix>:d2:14:21).

I'm still concerned about the constant re-auth, but it's not toggling
around semi-randomly like before.

-- 
D. Ben Knoble

Reply via email to