On Thursday 26 January 2006 22:09, Jason Stubbs wrote:
> There is no way that I can see around this without highly increasing the 
> possibility of false positives.

I extracted a list of cps from repoman, modified your script to check all cpvs 
(rather than only the best) and compared that with repoman's cps. The 
attached result.diff file prefixes repoman-only detection with a "-" and the 
separate tool-only detection with a "+".

Your fixes to seem to producee many false positives and introduce some false 
negatives as well. There may be true positives that I'm missing but I 
couldn't find one picking a few cases at random.

Either way, it doesn't matter if there a few false negatives as it's only 
meant to be an aid. False positives on the other hand are unacceptable.

--
Jason Stubbs
+app-accessibility/gok
-app-cdr/nero
+app-editors/nvu
+app-editors/vim
+app-editors/zoinks
-app-emulation/cedega
+app-emulation/dosemu
-app-emulation/pearpc
-app-emulation/point2play
+app-emulation/vice
-app-emulation/vmware-workstation
+app-emulation/wine
-app-emulation/winex-transgaming
+app-i18n/kinput2
-app-i18n/uim-svn
+app-misc/beagle
+app-misc/oneko
-app-misc/tkpasman
-app-office/mozilla-sunbird-bin
+app-office/magicpoint
+app-office/openoffice
+app-office/openoffice-ximian
-app-pda/qtopia-desktop-bin
-app-portage/portagemaster
+app-portage/test
+app-shells/fish
+app-text/cstetex
+app-text/gv
+app-text/ptex
-dev-embedded/ponyprog
+dev-games/ode
-dev-java/gnu-classpath
+dev-java/blackdown-jre
-dev-lang/smalltalkx
+dev-lang/swi-prolog-lite
-dev-lisp/mit-scheme
+dev-util/insight
-dev-util/weka
-games-action/phobiaiii
+games-action/tuxkart
+games-action/xpilot
+games-action/xpilot-ng
-games-arcade/emergence-bin
+games-arcade/koules
-games-arcade/mtp-target-bin
+games-arcade/ppracer
+games-arcade/xgalaga
+games-arcade/xjump
+games-board/cgoban
-games-emulation/boycott-advance-sdl
-games-emulation/dgen-sdl
-games-emulation/hugo
-games-emulation/kigb
-games-emulation/mastergear-bin
+games-emulation/snes9x
-games-emulation/vgba
-games-fps/fuhquake-bin
-games-fps/postal2mpdemo
-games-fps/unreal
-games-fps/vendetta-online-bin
-games-puzzle/pauker
-games-puzzle/triptych-demo
+games-puzzle/xwelltris
+games-roguelike/nethack
-games-server/WarpPipe
+games-server/crossfire-server
+games-sports/miniracer
+games-sports/ultimatestunts
+games-strategy/freeciv
+gnome-base/control-center
+gnome-base/nautilus
-mail-client/ciphire-mail
-mail-client/mozilla-thunderbird-bin
+kde-base/kdesktop
+mail-client/mozilla-thunderbird
+media-fonts/x11fonts-jmk
+media-gfx/fbida
-media-gfx/povtree
-media-libs/devil
+media-libs/gd
+media-libs/giblib
+media-libs/glide-v3
-media-libs/hamlib
+media-libs/libcaca
+media-libs/libmpeg2
+media-libs/libquicktime
+media-libs/plib
+media-libs/urt
-media-libs/xpm
+media-plugins/libvisual-plugins
-media-radio/tucnak1
-media-radio/xconvers
-media-radio/xdx
-media-radio/xlog
-media-sound/mup
+media-tv/kdetv
+media-tv/xdtv
+media-video/motioneye
+media-video/mplayer
+media-video/xanim
-media-video/yanc
+net-analyzer/sara
-net-im/ymessenger
+net-libs/gecko-sdk
-net-misc/ltsp
-net-misc/mindterm
-net-misc/nxserver-business
-net-misc/nxserver-enterprise
-net-misc/nxserver-personal
+net-misc/vnc
-net-misc/xsmbrowser
-net-nntp/bnr2
-net-p2p/phex
+net-print/xpp
+net-www/gnash
+net-www/mplayerplug-in
+sci-chemistry/ghemical
+sci-chemistry/gopenmol
-sci-chemistry/nmrpipe
-sci-chemistry/nmrview
+sci-chemistry/rasmol
+sci-chemistry/viewmol
+sci-electronics/spice
+sci-libs/libgdgeda
+sci-misc/boinc
+sys-apps/pcmcia-cs
+sys-devel/gcc
+www-client/elinks
-www-client/mozilla-bin
-www-client/mozilla-firefox-bin
+www-client/mozilla
+www-client/mozilla-firefox
-www-client/opera
+x11-libs/Xaw3d
+x11-libs/libdockapp
+x11-libs/libxsettings-client
+x11-libs/qt
+x11-libs/startup-notification
+x11-misc/3ddesktop
+x11-misc/accessx
+x11-misc/autocutsel
-x11-misc/commonbox-utils
+x11-misc/chgres
+x11-misc/dclock
+x11-misc/electricsheep
+x11-misc/fireflies
+x11-misc/fspanel
+x11-misc/fxred
+x11-misc/hsetroot
+x11-misc/imwheel
+x11-misc/mixer_app
+x11-misc/numlockx
+x11-misc/obpager
+x11-misc/pogo
+x11-misc/seyon
+x11-misc/skippy
+x11-misc/temperature-app
+x11-misc/transset
+x11-misc/vnc2swf
+x11-misc/wayv
+x11-misc/x2vnc
+x11-misc/x2x
+x11-misc/xautomation
+x11-misc/xbatt
+x11-misc/xbattbar
+x11-misc/xcalendar
+x11-misc/xcb
+x11-misc/xclip
+x11-misc/xcompmgr
+x11-misc/xcut
+x11-misc/xdaf
+x11-misc/xdaliclock
+x11-misc/xearth
+x11-misc/xfishtank
+x11-misc/xfm
+x11-misc/xhkeys
+x11-misc/xinput
+x11-misc/xkbd
+x11-misc/xkeycaps
+x11-misc/xmountains
+x11-misc/xnc
+x11-misc/xnview
+x11-misc/xplanet
+x11-misc/xrestop
+x11-misc/xrmap
+x11-misc/xsetleds
+x11-misc/xsimpsons
+x11-misc/xsnap
+x11-misc/xsnow
+x11-misc/xstroke
+x11-misc/xteddy
+x11-misc/xtoolwait
+x11-misc/xtrlock
+x11-misc/xvidcap
+x11-misc/xvkbd
+x11-misc/xwit
+x11-misc/xwrits
+x11-misc/xxkb
+x11-plugins/allin1
+x11-plugins/cputnik
+x11-plugins/enigmail
+x11-plugins/wmCalClock
+x11-plugins/wmMatrix
+x11-plugins/wmMoonClock
+x11-plugins/wmSMPmon
+x11-plugins/wmSpaceWeather
+x11-plugins/wmSun
+x11-plugins/wmacpiload-ac
+x11-plugins/wmacpimon
+x11-plugins/wmalms
+x11-plugins/wmapm
+x11-plugins/wmapmload
+x11-plugins/wmappl
+x11-plugins/wmbatteries
+x11-plugins/wmbattery
+x11-plugins/wmbinclock
+x11-plugins/wmbio
+x11-plugins/wmbluecpu
+x11-plugins/wmbutton
+x11-plugins/wmcalc
+x11-plugins/wmcdplay
+x11-plugins/wmclock
+x11-plugins/wmcp
+x11-plugins/wmcpuload
+x11-plugins/wmcube
+x11-plugins/wmdf
+x11-plugins/wmdiskmon
+x11-plugins/wmdl
+x11-plugins/wmdots
+x11-plugins/wmfire
+x11-plugins/wmfsm
+x11-plugins/wmget
-x11-plugins/wmpager
+x11-plugins/wmppp
+x11-plugins/wmwifi
+x11-terms/xterm
+x11-wm/enlightenment
-x11-wm/pawm
+x11-wm/wmi
+xfce-extra/xfce4-minicmd

Reply via email to