Leo Simons wrote:
In this case, Noel has raised some perfectly valid concerns about files living on http://www.apache.org/dist/ without a PMC putting them there (which is a *big thing*, for legal and other reasons). If I were lenya, I wouldn't complain about constraints, but just address those concerns.
well, IIRC then concerns have been addressed promptly.
No, they have not been addressed promptly. There exists content on
http://www.apache.org/dist/cocoon/lenya/
which is not supposed to be there. I'll quote Noel:
"Thinking on it, we should probably delete those files, which were never
approved by either the Incubator or Cocoon PMCs. Baring commentary to the contrary, I will do so within the next day or so (leaving time for
legitimate contrary views)."
What lenya should ideally be doing now is providing commentary and evidence to the contrary, explaining and de-escalating the situation. If that's not possible, lenya should perhaps attempt to come up with reasonable and less drastic measures (removing then re-adding files to the distribution server pushes changes to dozens of mirrors) that are agreeable to the incubator as well. Furthermore, lenya should do all the neccessary work to alleviate all concerns (not Noel, not the incubator).
C'mon guys, a mistake or two have been made, which is fine! That's why we have an incubation process in the first place :-D. Live and learn. Go fix things. Don't draw lines in the sand.
As a general note I would like to say, that future concerns should be addressed to individuals and not to Wyona as a company.
Well in some cases it /is/ relevant that a large part of lenya individuals are wyona employees. While its a task of lenya (not individuals there; the responsibility AFAIC is collective) to make sure there's no reason for concern wrt all this stuff, I think everyone recognizes wyona, the company, has a part to play there as well. Right?
Also I think it would be of great help if issues are being sent to the Lenya community directly and or the individuals involved.
duly noted, and lenya-dev added back to CC list. Guys, you may have missed some useful bits of info. Please go read recent [EMAIL PROTECTED] archives to make sure you haven't.
- Leo
--------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
