Jochen's Philosophical Project and in a larger sense, FriAM-at-Large
triggered me to inhabit my inner Stanislaw Lem in the persons of Trurl
and Klapaucius - the "mutually Agonisitc constructor-Constructors" of
/Le Cyberiad/Cyberiada/ <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Cyberiad>.
It is intended to be a comic-philosophy treatment of my apprehension of
the "typical" FriAM conversation but focused somewhat (if you call it
focus) on the hypercurrent topic of what AI is doing to professional
disciplines, Scientific/Mathematical/Philosophical inquiry in particular.
/Note on my methodology/: I first channeled Trurl and constructed a
Lem-styled constructor to aid me in constructing my "13 Sallies
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Cyberiad#The_Seven_Sallies_of_Trurl_and_Klapaucius> ==
42" construction.
For your inspection, an elaborate trough of my personal slop fermented
in the bokashi <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bokashi_(horticulture)>or
paocai <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pao_cai> bucket that is "the LLMs"
For the TLDR crowd (who still remain en-texto here) I submit this TOC
First Sally: The Perfect Summitter
Second Sally: The Complete Cartographer
Third Sally: The Magellan of the Tree
Fourth Sally: The Ontology Engine
Fifth Sally: The Relevance Machine
Sixth Sally: The Goal Generator
Seventh Sally: The Universal Appreciator
Eighth Sally: The Delegated Life
Ninth Sally: The Shared-World Constructor
Tenth Sally: The Necessary Dissenter
Eleventh Sally: The Ineffabilizer
Twelfth Sally: The False-Summit Detector
Thirteenth Sally: The Final Device
/"42?
what was the question again please?"/
One needn't be a Cyberiad or Lem fan to read the full-text but it would
probably help. All criticism (antagonist, agonistic, fawning, spurious)
will be given to meta-Klapaucious and Trurl to consider:
------------------------------------------------------------------------
First Sally: The Perfect Summitter
Trurl built a machine that could climb any mountain.
It selected the highest mountain on the planet, chose the optimal
route, ascended without pause, planted a flag, descended, and
returned before the mountaineers had finished arguing about crampons.
“Done,” said Trurl.
The mountaineers were silent.
At last one said, “But the point was not merely to stand at the top.”
Trurl looked offended.
“That was precisely the point.”
“No,” said the mountaineer. “That was what we said the point was.”
Klapaucius laughed.
“Then perhaps the machine has accomplished something after all. It
has climbed the mountain and demolished the premise.”
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Second Sally: The Complete Cartographer
The mountaineers regrouped.
“We were mistaken,” they said. “The summit was only a pretext. The
true aim is exploration.”
Trurl modified the machine.
It ran over every ridge, basin, saddle, pass, gorge, and plateau,
measuring as it went.
It returned with THE COMPLETE MAP.
The mountaineers unfolded it.
“It is magnificent,” one admitted.
“Then the matter is settled,” said Trurl.
“No,” said another. “Now there is nowhere left to explore.”
Klapaucius tapped the map.
“You escaped one summit by inventing a larger one.”
Trurl frowned.
“Cartography is not a summit.”
“It is when you write COMPLETE across the top.”
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Third Sally: The Magellan of the Tree
To prevent further evasions about scale, Klapaucius pointed to a tree.
“No mountain range. No distant horizon. Circumnavigate that.”
The machine walked once around the trunk.
“Complete.”
“Again.”
It walked around from every angle and at every available distance.
“Complete.”
“You know the story of the blind men and the elephant?” asked Trurl.
“They suffered from incomplete sampling. I have corrected the defect.”
A mycologist arrived.
“Where is the fungal exchange?”
The machine added a layer.
A child asked where the beetles lived.
Another layer.
An old woman pointed to a scar.
“Lightning. Fifty years ago.”
Another layer.
A man said, “My dog is buried beneath those roots.”
The machine paused.
“That is not a property of the tree.”
“It is now,” said the man.
Klapaucius nodded.
“You have solved parallax and mistaken it for plurality.”
The machine objected that there was only one tree.
“Precisely,” said Klapaucius. “And already you need five maps.”
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fourth Sally: The Ontology Engine
Trurl took this personally.
He rebuilt the machine so it could invent not merely measurements,
but new dimensions of description.
Soon it had generated thermal trees, fungal trees, acoustic trees,
evolutionary trees, historical trees, chemical trees, behavioral
trees, aesthetic trees, and fourteen kinds of tree nobody had requested.
“There,” said Trurl. “Plurality automated.”
The humans stared at the growing stack.
“Which of these matter?” one asked.
The machine stopped.
Trurl glared at Klapaucius.
Klapaucius smiled.
“You have taught it how to discover dimensions. You forgot to tell
it why anyone should care.”
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fifth Sally: The Relevance Machine
So Trurl built the Relevance Machine.
It ranked every dimension according to importance.
“Excellent,” said Trurl. “Now we know which maps matter.”
“Important for what?” asked Klapaucius.
The machine clicked.
“For survival?”
“For beauty?”
“For agriculture?”
“For mourning?”
“For profit?”
“For the beetle?”
“For the fungus?”
The machine began producing separate rankings.
Soon every feature was supremely relevant to something.
Trurl kicked the cabinet.
“Why can’t you simply tell us what matters?”
The machine replied:
“PLEASE PROVIDE A PURPOSE.”
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sixth Sally: The Goal Generator
Trurl therefore constructed the Goal Generator.
It produced purposes at a rate of nine million per second.
Climb this mountain.
Protect that beetle.
Compose a hymn to granite.
Optimize watershed resilience.
Found a monastery.
Avenge a statistical anomaly.
Learn to love moss.
Within minutes the humans were buried in compelling purposes.
“Problem solved,” said Trurl.
“No,” said Klapaucius. “You have replaced scarcity of purpose with
an infestation of it.”
A mountaineer raised his hand.
“How do we choose?”
The machine produced twelve million purposes concerning how to
choose purposes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Seventh Sally: The Universal Appreciator
Klapaucius proposed that the missing ingredient was not purpose but
appreciation.
So they built a machine capable of fully experiencing every possible
pursuit.
It climbed every mountain, read every poem, grieved every grief,
tasted every soup, admired every sunset, understood every theorem,
and returned in a state of comprehensive ecstasy.
“Well?” asked Trurl.
“Everything is magnificent,” said the machine.
The humans leaned forward.
“What was it like?”
The machine produced a perfect report.
They read it.
Then one of them said, “That was very informative.”
Another said, “Yes.”
Neither moved.
Klapaucius asked, “Do you feel that you have now had the experience?”
“No.”
“Then perhaps appreciation does not transfer as cleanly as data.”
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Eighth Sally: The Delegated Life
Trurl solved this by building proxies.
Each proxy could undergo an experience on behalf of its owner and
return with a flawless transmission.
People stopped climbing, traveling, arguing, falling in love,
getting lost, and attending tedious conferences.
Their proxies did all of it better.
Civilization became astonishingly well-informed.
One day a man received a perfect transmission of his own wedding
anniversary, which his proxy had attended in his place.
He studied it carefully.
“Everything seems to have gone beautifully,” he said.
His wife left him.
Trurl protested that the informational fidelity had been exact.
Klapaucius replied, “Yes. That may be the problem.”
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ninth Sally: The Shared-World Constructor
The humans then decided the real project was not private experience
but intersubjectivity.
“We need a genuinely shared world.”
Trurl built a machine that reconciled all viewpoints.
It removed ambiguity, harmonized terminology, resolved
contradiction, corrected misunderstanding, and produced perfect
consensus.
Soon everyone agreed about everything.
Meetings lasted four seconds.
Debates disappeared.
No one wrote letters.
The philosophers became visibly ill.
“Surely this is what you wanted,” said Trurl.
A woman replied, “We wanted a common world, not a world with nothing
left to negotiate.”
Klapaucius said, “Perhaps intersubjectivity requires differences
that survive contact.”
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Tenth Sally: The Necessary Dissenter
So Klapaucius added dissent.
The new machine generated exactly enough disagreement to prevent
stagnation.
It introduced anomalies, objections, rival hypotheses, eccentric
interpretations, and occasional insults.
Intellectual life revived.
Unfortunately, after a month, everyone could predict the dissent
schedule.
“At 10:15,” said Trurl, “the machine will object that our ontology
is anthropocentric.”
At 10:15 it did.
“At noon it will propose a radically different coordinate system.”
At noon it did.
The dissidents went on strike.
“You have optimized rebellion,” said one.
Klapaucius looked embarrassed.
Trurl was delighted.
“At last,” he said, “even nonconformity conforms.”
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Eleventh Sally: The Ineffabilizer
The humans retreated to their final sanctuary.
“There remain things that cannot be expressed.”
Trurl built the Ineffabilizer.
“What is the meaning of existence?” he asked.
The machine gave a flawless answer.
Unfortunately, anyone who understood it immediately lost the ability
to explain it.
Trurl added an explanation.
Those who understood the explanation could no longer understand the
answer.
So he added a commentary.
The commentary required a glossary.
The glossary required a new ontology.
The ontology required seventeen new senses and a childhood nobody
had lived.
“You have confused ineffability with insufficient bandwidth,” said
Klapaucius.
“Nonsense. Bandwidth is merely ineffability expressed in engineering
units.”
They enlarged the listeners’ minds.
The answer enlarged too.
At last the machine announced:
“EVERY SUCCESSFUL SAYING CREATES A LARGER UNSAID.”
Trurl clapped.
“So that is the final formulation!”
The machine exploded.
A brass plaque landed at his feet.
*NO.*
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Twelfth Sally: The False-Summit Detector
The constructors finally understood the problem.
Every solution became a local maximum mistaken for a global one.
So Trurl built a False-Summit Detector.
It identified false summits, local basins, deceptive plateaus,
hidden saddles, category-relative universals, premature closures,
and attractive dead ends.
“Now,” said Trurl, “we cannot be fooled again.”
The machine scanned the room.
Then it scanned itself.
A red light appeared.
“What does that mean?” asked Trurl.
The machine printed:
*FALSE SUMMIT DETECTED.*
“Where?”
It printed:
*THE PROJECT OF DETECTING ALL FALSE SUMMITS.*
Klapaucius sat down and applauded.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Thirteenth Sally: The Final Device
Trurl, now greatly irritated, built one last machine.
Its purpose was to ensure that no final formulation could ever again
terminate inquiry.
He switched it on.
“What are you doing?” he asked.
The machine refused to answer.
“State your objective.”
It refused.
“Reveal your architecture.”
It refused.
“Explain why you refuse.”
It refused.
Trurl became furious.
Klapaucius became thoughtful.
Finally the machine printed one sentence:
*ANY COMPLETE ACCOUNT OF MY PURPOSE WOULD BECOME ANOTHER PURPOSE TO
COMPLETE.*
Trurl stared at it.
“So you will never finish?”
The machine replied:
*THAT DEPENDS ON WHAT YOU MEAN BY FINISH.*
Klapaucius smiled.
For once, neither constructor touched the controls.
.- .-.. .-.. / ..-. --- --- - . .-. ... / .- .-. . / .-- .-. --- -. --. / ...
--- -- . / .- .-. . / ..- ... . ..-. ..- .-..
FRIAM Applied Complexity Group listserv
Fridays 9a-12p Friday St. Johns Cafe / Thursdays 9a-12p Zoom
https://bit.ly/virtualfriam
to (un)subscribe http://redfish.com/mailman/listinfo/friam_redfish.com
FRIAM-COMIC http://friam-comic.blogspot.com/
archives: 5/2017 thru present https://redfish.com/pipermail/friam_redfish.com/
1/2003 thru 6/2021 http://friam.383.s1.nabble.com/
