Hi Jim,

> On Sun, Mar 17, 2024 at 6:26 AM Liam Proven via Freedos-user
> <freedos-user@lists.sourceforge.net> wrote:
> [..]
>> There are good reasons that DOS went away some 35 years ago. It has
>> its uses but not being able to flip to another window or another
>> screen to consult documentation, or try something out, or look it up
>> online, is a *massive* handicap.

+1

> That's a very interesting way of "advocating" FreeDOS, and "helping"
> folks who are new to FreeDOS.
I think Liam's post was not about "advocating" FreeDOS, but about "helping"
a nooby user.



> Here we have a person who discovered FreeDOS, who wants to experiment
> with FreeDOS by writing programs with it, and was looking for pointers
> to get started. 
Nope. AFAICT it's a person wanting to learn programming; no mentioning of 
FreeDOS.

And learning FreeDOS and learning programming at the same time is taking Two 
steps at once.
Usually not a smart idea.


> It's a very odd reaction to immediately tell that
> person to go find another operating system. That's not very welcoming.

> If someone discovers FreeDOS and wants to explore FreeDOS, we should
> help them find a way to "Yes" and not to "No."
it should be a serious reply.
in this case I'd vote "probaly not unless the original BASIC is a DOS based 
BASIC".
even then use a 32 Bit version of Windows(if the intended use case is learning 
to program). 


> And if something goes really wrong (like you did
> something weird in a new program you wrote, and it crashes and locks
> up the system) you just reboot.

I simply guarantee that you won't be able to write a program that crashes any 
version of modern Windows Dosbox.
I fail to see the advantage.

Tom  



_______________________________________________
Freedos-user mailing list
Freedos-user@lists.sourceforge.net
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/freedos-user

Reply via email to