Bastien <[email protected]> writes:

> Morgan Smith <[email protected]> writes:
>
>> I don't know if I can convince myself to open a feature request that
>> contains the "Canceled" keyword.  To me that is quite strange and blurs
>> the line between where the bug report stops and the feature request
>> starts.
>
> I understand - then why not sending an email to close the bug report and
> another one to open the feature request?

I have nothing against this approach.  This is probably what I'll be
doing for the foreseeable future :)

>> However, I'm not a fan of "context".  I much prefer things that are
>> globally applicable.
>
> I'm with you here -- the first iteration (Woof!) was relying on too many
> contexts, BONE is less complex... happy to consider other cognitive load
> that we can spare.
>
>> For example, it's a little strange that using the "Confirmed" keyword in
>> the initial bug report doesn't mark it as confirmed.  So I have to keep
>> in mind that that keyword only works in certain contexts.
>
> Oh why did it not work?  "Confirmed" always confirm bug, FR, patches.

Maybe not the best example to give as I suddenly switched to talking
about a different "context".  Here I'm specifically talking about how it
doesn't work in the *initial* report.

So this report here is not acked:

https://list.orgmode.org/ch3pr84mb342413ebc2dd0045ec233792c5...@ch3pr84mb3424.namprd84.prod.outlook.com

>> For this specific issue, I have to keep in mind that feature requests
>> and bugs operate with their own contexts that make certain operations
>> work and others not.
>
> Let's work on that - the stable source of truth is the BONE manual:
> https://tracker.orgmode.org/bone-manual.html
>
> Happy to consider any simplification to remove complexity linked to
> keeping context in mind if that makes sense.
>
> (I won't be able to code or even participate actively in a discussion
> this week, but will read the thread as soon as I can.)

So I haven't actually read the manual.  I really should :P.

Ok.  I'm going to take some time, consolidate my notes, read the manual,
and then open a new thread that contains my thoughts on BONE.  Look
forward to that!

Thank you for being so receptive!

Morgan

Reply via email to