Philippe Laliberte wrote: > Damien Sandras wrote: >> Le lundi 22 octobre 2007 à 11:52 +0100, Philippe Laliberte a écrit : >> >>> ael wrote: >>>> P laliberte wrote: >>>> >>>>> ael wrote: >>>>> >>>>>> Philippe Laliberte wrote: >>>>>> >>>>>> >>>>>>> Hello, >>>>>>> >>>>>>> I am running into a little problem. I did dig into the wiki but >>>>>>> to no >>>>>>> avail. >>>>>>> >>>>>>> Set-up: >>>>>>> >>>>>>> Fedora 7. >>>>>>> kernel-2.6.22.9 >>>>>>> Firewall disabled. selinux disabled >>>>>>> Ekiga 2.0.11 >>>>>>> >>>>>>> Router Modem ADSL SpeedTouch 780 >>>>>>> Firewall disabled (once I get Ekiga working I'll test what I can >>>>>>> close) >>>>>>> VoIp turned off >>>>>>> >>>>>>> Modem routing Configuration >>>>>>> >>>>>>> Protocol Port Range Translate To ... Trigger Protocol >>>>>>> Trigger Port Any 5000 - 5100 5000 - 5100 >>>>>>> - - >>>>>>> UDP 3479 - 3479 3479 - 3479 >>>>>>> UDP 3479 >>>>>>> UDP 3478 - 3479 3478 - 3479 >>>>>>> UDP 3478 >>>>>>> >>>>>> I can't quite decode the above. If you trigger on 3478 (UDP) and then >>>>>> open 5000 -5100 (UDP) then it should be ok. I am not sure that is >>>>>> what >>>>>> you have above is it? I can't make out the first line ending in >>>>>> 5000-5100: how does that relate to the two following lines? >>>>>> >>>>>> ael >>>>>> _______________________________________________ >>>>>> ekiga-list mailing list >>>>>> ekiga-list@gnome.org >>>>>> http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list >>>>>> >>>>> Just missing a cariage return >>>>> >>>>> Protocol Port Range Translate To ... Trigger Protocol >>>>> Trigger >>>>> Port Any 5000 - 5100 5000 - 5100 - - >>>>> UDP 3479 - 3479 3479 - 3479 UDP 3479 >>>>> UDP 3478 - 3479 3478 - 3479 UDP 3478 >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> What you mean is that I should just do : >>>>> >>>>> UDP 5000 - 5100 3479 - 3479 UDP 3479 >>>>> UDP 5100 - 5100 3478 - 3479 UDP 3478 >>>>> >>>> Looking at that again, why are you translating 3479 into 5000-5100? Or >>>> am I misunderstanding the web interface (I assume)? >>>> >>>> Once you see a packet on 3478, then open 5000-5100. Do not translate >>>> 3478 into 5000... if that is what the above means. 3478 and 3479 should >>>> be (con) tracked properly by the router. It is just that it will block >>>> 5000-5100 unless it is told otherwise. >>>> >>>> I have not encountered a SpeedTouch router so I may be misunderstanding >>>> its configuration. >>>> >>>> ael >>>> >>> The error is mine, late doing too many thing at the same time. You did >>> understand it correctly the first time. >>> UDP 5000 - 5100 5000 - 5100 UDP 3479 >>> UDP 5100 - 5100 5000 - 5100 UDP 3478 >>> I'll test it later this afternoon thanks. >>> >>> >> >> Why 5100 - 5100 ? >> >> > > Well unconclusive: > > UDP 5000 - 5100 5000 - 5100 UDP 3479 > UDP 5000 - 5100 5000 - 5100 UDP 3478 > > > Wizard, still in symetric NAT > > Manual STUN: No sound on [EMAIL PROTECTED], no calls in from Diamoncard even > after a fresh restart > None: [EMAIL PROTECTED] ok, no calls in from Diamoncard even after a fresh > restart. > > > Back to no trigger definition, same as above. > > Back to TCP/UDP > > Any 5000 - 5100 5000 - 5100 Any 3478 > Any 5000 - 5100 5000 - 5100 Any 3479 > > Wizard, still in symetric NAT > > STUN: No sound on [EMAIL PROTECTED], Calls in from Diamoncard OK even after > a while, after manual changes back and forth it does not work anymore > > None: [EMAIL PROTECTED] ok, no calls in from Diamoncard even after a fresh > restart. > > Back to no trigger definition, same as above. > > Wireshark shows SIP activity for the [EMAIL PROTECTED] call but nothing coming > in from Diamoncard. > > Can all this working not working be related to a slowness from > diamoncard or the router to react to changes? I am connected to > eugw.ast.diamondcard.us. If I try to setup my VoIp on the modem, it > never seems to register. > > I'll go back to STUN (with trigger of the router) and shutdown Ekiga for > an hour or so to see if when I come back It will work.
You have looked at http://wiki.ekiga.org/index.php/Ekiga_behind_a_NAT_router , I assume? ael _______________________________________________ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
