Speaking only for myself (and definitely not for my employer, GoDaddy)...
On Sun, Oct 16, 2022 at 11:45 PM Eliot Lear <[email protected]> wrote:
>
> On 17.10.22 04:20, Paul Wouters wrote:
>
> > Basically, .alt is what IETF recommends you should not do, and we
> > should not keep
> > a registry of entries within it.
>
> We cannot assume that DNS will forever be the only Good approach and
> that all others will forever be Bad. Given that, we as a community are
> obligated to search for better, and to try new things. As I wrote
> earlier, I do not know that GNS will succeed. I do hope and expect that
> the community will learn something from some deployment experience of
> that protocol so that the next one can be better.
>
>
I think that the concerns of namespace and root(s) is essentially this:
- The Domain Name System has the ICANN Root as its source of legitimacy,
and the IETF as its standards body.
- Other namespaces need to be effectively "ships in the night" with
respect to The Domain Name System
- This means no interoperation between "not-DNS" and "DNS" at a name
space layer.
- Specifically, as long as any other name resolution scheme has no
overlap with any portion of the DNS tree, what names that other system
contains is a moot point (even if they superficially appear to collide)
- The alternative (allowing non-DNS services to also directly
incorporate the DNS tree) has a high likelihood of causing user confusion
or worse.
- Any alternative systems should stand entirely on their own, and
their success or failure would be possible to objectively assess.
- The only place where multiple systems (DNS and any non-DNS) should
be combined is the same place they have always been,
/etc/nsswitch.conf (or
equivalent)
- Experimentation and development of standards can only happen safely
when unrelated systems don't overlap or conflict.
- This suggestion would be the antithesis of the "Good vs Bad"
viewpoint, and IMNSHO consistent with what DNSOP does already.
Brian
_______________________________________________
DNSOP mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dnsop
