On Mon, 4 Jul 2011 12:20:02 +0100, Ethan Grammatikidis <eeke...@fastmail.fm> 
wrote:
> On Sun, 12 Jun 2011 22:23:03 +0200
> pancake <panc...@youterm.com> wrote:
> 
> > Also crt and lcd/tft screens have differet brightness effects. Tft are less 
> > damaging to eyes than crt.. So i think discussion about colors on text 
> > moved to only stethical and personal issue because its no longer dramatic 
> > as it was in the crt era.
> 
> Really? Who made this screaming bullshit up? My eyes haven't been right since 
> I bought my first TFT monitor, and I've run into several people ONLINE who 
> tell me they can't use LCD monitors AT ALL. Imagine that; relying on the 
> internet and yet you can't use LCDs. Given how many people would simply 
> forget about using computers if they had such a problem, I expect LCD screens 
> make a LOT of peoples' eyes bleed. I think you're blindly believing _lies_ 
> spewed by monitor manufacturers.
> 
> Pancake... I'm sorry to say this but I get a "wtf moment" from nearly every 
> post you send to this list. I realize that's not constructive criticism... 
> You may want to consider how information flows especially how and when it it 
> is possible to determine truth from lies. I don't mean how data flows; I mean 
> how _meaning_ gets passed from human to human, and what can be lost in 
> transit, especially when the sending humans are working on behalf of a 
> megacorp (or government, for that matter).
> 

While I won't comment on the rest of pancake's message
(I've already done so for one of his other points):

You can verify all this CRT-related "screaming bullshit" [sic]
empirically, in the comfort of your own home:

Eye-related:
+ greater contrast ratio and color depth (degrades over time)
+ multisync (= scaling to different resolutions)
+ higher response time
- constant flicker
- image loss/distortion at boundaries
- uneven brightness
- more susceptible to glare
- difficult to position ergonomically

Other:
+ cheap
- prone to imploding (and setting fire to the elderly)
- emits high-pitched tone
- wasteful:
  - greater size (especially considering equivalent viewing area)
  - higher weight
  - higher power consumption (+ heat output)


(ionizing radiation and "filled to the brim with toxic crap" omitted
due to requiring specialized equipment to determine)


Peace

-- 
Pieter

Reply via email to