Hi Justin, I checked the box that Iceberg is "nearing graduation", not that it is ready to graduate. I think the numbers show that we've had good community growth and we have added a PPMC member. Adding more and actually getting a release out are the points that I've listed as the unfinished steps before graduation.
As an ASF mentor, I think that this community is doing well adopting the Apache Way, which is why I think it is nearing graduation. To call out a couple: discussion is open and happens on the dev list or issue tracker; and artifacts have license documentation that complies with ASF policy (the major hurdle to the first release). rb On Fri, Sep 6, 2019 at 12:19 AM Justin Mclean <jmcl...@apache.org> wrote: > Hi, > > I can a couple of concern about the report, first off I don't think any > project would be ready to graduate if they have not made a release or added > committers/PPMC members. And it would be grate to see some something other > than meaningless stats on community growth in the report. Those numbers may > mean something to people in the project, but they don't mean a lot outside > of it. Try to write the report as if it was going to be read by something > who knew very little about your project and > > So why does the project think it's ready to graduate? Mentors do you think > the project is ready to graduate? > > Thanks, > Justin > -- Ryan Blue Software Engineer Netflix
