Hi,
>>"Marcus" == Marcus Brinkmann <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes:
Marcus> Hello,
Marcus> this is was RMS told me about this topic. I think it is
Marcus> relevant for the discussion. It contains an example where a
Marcus> free standard would have been useful and provides yet another
Marcus> solution for standard authors to protect the integrity of
Marcus> their standard.
I agree. I also say it applies to licenses as well. If not,
please provide reasons (which I shall turn around and use for
standards, then).
Marcus> There are now many ways for authors to do this:
Marcus> a) Require a name change.
Marcus> b) Reuqire clear marks where the document has been changed.
Marcus> c) Require original source with diff.
Marcus> d) Require that a non-technical part is only shipped with the verbatim
Marcus> standard (see below).
Marcus> I think this is sufficient to address Manojs fears about the
Marcus> integritation of the standard.
Yup. It would also work for Licenses.
Marcus> Manoj, if you still think that derived works will be
Marcus> problematic for the community, despite the four possibilities
Marcus> above, it is your turn to give technical arguments why the
Marcus> integrity of standard documents needs even more protection.
No, no. I concede this point. I also think it applies to
licenses. I think RMS is being very hypocritical for not using this
license for the GPL.
I am going to insist on the same treatment fot licenses as for
standards. Also, the DFSG and the social contract are not even
licenses.
Give me reasons all these are not DFSG free, and why they
should nt be. And, I shall use your arguments for the standards as
well, so be careful in what you say ;-)
manoj
--
"All Marxists, basically, are reactionaries, yearning for the
Oriental despotisms of pre-Hellenic times, the neolithic culture that
preceded the rise of self-consciousness and egoism." Robert Anton
Wilson, writing as "Justin Case".
Manoj Srivastava <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> <http://www.datasync.com/%7Esrivasta/>
Key C7261095 fingerprint = CB D9 F4 12 68 07 E4 05 CC 2D 27 12 1D F5 E8 6E
