Hi Tiago,

On 2025-01-17 14:51, Tiago Bortoletto Vaz wrote:
> It is very much appreciated that you were diligent and consulted
> documentation (and this list) before trying to sponsor packages as a DM.
> Technically, it's not possible. See:
> 
> https://wiki.debian.org/DebianMaintainer#Granting_Permissions

I think there might be a misunderstanding here: the above article is
about granting someone else upload privileges. Whereas here, we have a
DM who already has upload privileges, who would upload a version of a
team-maintained package that was prepared by another team member who
themselves aren't a DM yet.

This obviously cannot be a problem if contributions to the new version
were split 50/50 or even 80/20 between the DM and non-DM, as that is the
nature of a team-maintained package.

I posit that it shouldn't be a problem for the DM to upload even in the
0/100 case. If the DM is given trust do to uploads, that implies trust
that the DM will review the uploads, and has the necessary skills to
identify and correct any defects, including those caused by other team
members (DD or not).

This is just the "formal" view. On a technical level, I don't see what
could stop a DM for going ahead with this regardless, as the only
obstacle could possibly be the Changes line, and the DM could simply
change that before upload.

Best,
Christian

Reply via email to