On Tue, Jan 23, 2001 at 08:01:27PM +0100, Davide Puricelli wrote: > Hi, I'd like to hear some comments about OpenDivX license that it's attached > below: > > DivX Open License > ================= > Version 1.0 > > Copyright (C) 2001 Project Mayo. Everyone is permitted to copy and > distribute verbatim copies of this license document, but changing it > is not allowed. > > Provided below is our open source license agreement ("License") under > which we provide the Codec (defined below) to you free of charge. > Please read it carefully. > > BY USING, COPYING, MODIFYING, OR DISTRIBUTING THE CODEC OR A LARGER > WORK (DEFINED BELOW), YOU INDICATE YOUR ACCEPTANCE OF THIS LICENSE TO > DO SO, AND ALL ITS TERMS AND CONDITIONS. >
It's not an open source license. Term #6 places limitations on distributing modified copies. The license attempts to place restrictions on actions beyond the scope of copyright via a clickwrap/shrinkwrap/implicit acceptance mechanism. Additionaly, it attempts to discriminate against use by persons engaged in certain fields of endeavor. If term #6 were changed to read that non-conforming implementations could not be distributed if they were called DivX, striking the words USING and MODIFYING from the acceptance paragraph, and striking the words "personal" and "non-commercial" from the acceptance paragraph, we would be closer to an acceptable license. -- Brian Ristuccia [EMAIL PROTECTED] [EMAIL PROTECTED]
pgpnqoIOznvnu.pgp
Description: PGP signature