Scripsit "Bernhard R. Link" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > On 27 Jul 2000, Henning Makholm wrote:
> > Under the GPL, I must give the *rights* to everyone, because those who > > recive the program from me can pass it on to anyone, and this anyone > > also get full rights to my modifications. Essentially GPL says: > > 1) you must give your source to those you give binaries, but > > 2) you must give your rights to everyone. > I understood, that you have only give rights to all these, that receive > source or binaries directly or indirectly by you. Yes, but that is the same thing, because in practice *anyone* can be among those who get the souce *indirectly* from you. > If I modify some program written by you. And give it only give it > persons, from which I know, they will not distribute it further. > (Wihtout me forcing them to or making a licence "you are only > allowed to use, when ...". Would I have to give rights of the > modified form to you? Yes, if one of your friends later changes his mind and decides to give me a copy. As you cannot be *sure* whether or not your (current) friend will later change his mind, you had better be prepared to allow me to copy and modify your program. -- Henning Makholm "Det ville være så let at skabe et paradis. En fredfyldt, harmonisk verden."