OK I will reread it attentively
Le 27/10/2017 à 19:19, Hideki Kato a écrit : > Please read _through_ the paper sequentially. > #I don't have enough skill to describe the reason because > it's not a technical but language issue. > > Hideki > >> I don't understand which element makes you say that >> section 2 and 3 are all for a 20 block instance >> >> >> Le 27/10/2017 E01:49, Hideki Kato a écrit : >>> The 40 block version (2nd instance) first appeared in >>> Section 4 in the paper. Section 2 and 3 are all for the 1st >>> instance. >>> >>> Hideki >>> >>> Xavier Combelle: <39a79a0e-7c7d-2a01-a2ae-573cda8b1...@gmail.com>: >>>> Unless I mistake figure 3 shows the plot of supervised learning to >>>> reinforcement learning, not 20 bloc/40 block >>>> For searching mention of the 20 blocks I search for 20 in the whole >>>> paper and did not found any other mention >>>> than of the kifu thing. >>>> Le 26/10/2017 E15:10, Gian-Carlo Pascutto a écrit : >>>>> On 26-10-17 10:55, Xavier Combelle wrote: >>>>>> It is just wild guesses based on reasonable arguments but without >>>>>> evidence. >>>>> David Silver said they used 40 layers for AlphaGo Master. That's more >>>>> evidence than there is for the opposite argument that you are trying to >>>>> make. The paper certainly doesn't talk about a "small" and a "big" >>>> Master. >>>>> You seem to be arguing from a bunch of misreadings and >>>>> misunderstandings. For example, Figure 3 in the paper shows the Elo >> plot >>>>> for the 20 block/40 layer version, and it compares to Alpha Go Lee, not >>>>> Alpha Go Master. The Alpha Go Master line would be above the flattening >>>>> part of the 20 block/40 layer AlphaGo Zero. I guess you missed this >> when >>>>> you say that they "only mention it to compare on kifu prediction"? >>>> _______________________________________________ >>>> Computer-go mailing list >>>> Computer-go@computer-go.org >>>> http://computer-go.org/mailman/listinfo/computer-go >> _______________________________________________ >> Computer-go mailing list >> Computer-go@computer-go.org >> http://computer-go.org/mailman/listinfo/computer-go _______________________________________________ Computer-go mailing list Computer-go@computer-go.org http://computer-go.org/mailman/listinfo/computer-go
