On 04.09.2015 15:55, Stefan Kaitschick wrote:
Robert, David Fotland has paid his dues on "truly intelligent" go programs. Maybe more than anybody else. I find your critique a little painful. Don't blame David, that the "stupid" monte carlo works so much better.
So far I have not criticised but asked questions. I am a great fan of the expert system approach because a) I have studied go knowledge a lot and see, in principle, light at the end of the tunnel, b) I think that "MC + expert system" or "only expert system" can be better than MC if the expert system is well designed, c) an expert system can, in principle, provide more meaningful insight for us human duffers than an MC because the expert system can express itself in terms of reasoning. (Disclaimer: There is a good chance that I will criticise anybody presenting his definitions for use in an expert system. But who does not dare to be criticised does not learn!)
-- robert jasiek _______________________________________________ Computer-go mailing list Computer-go@computer-go.org http://computer-go.org/mailman/listinfo/computer-go
