On Fri, Feb 08, 2013 at 11:06:37AM -0800, Alex Huang wrote: > Hi everyone, > > I like to propose that we setup gerrit as the review mechanism. Here are my > reasons > > - Committer status in Apache is a reflection of one's commitment to the > community, not a reflection of understanding of code. So to me just because > you have committer status shouldn't mean code does not need review. Chip's > been doing a great job monitoring the merges and commits but one person > handling all that just means things will slip through. > - This also has the side effect of contributors' code contribution to be > treated as a second class citizen with delays in reviews because review is > not common place within our community. > - Direct commits have to be reverted if there are -1 votes, directly > impacting the time and effort of the code contributor. > > It makes a lot of sense to make code commit and review a normal process in > the CloudStack Community. > > --Alex > > >
+1 - And I think that other threads have come to a similar conclusion. Does anyone want to volunteer to get that up and running? We need someone to step up and do the work for this to become real. -chip
