+1 (binding) On Thu, Jan 17, 2013 at 11:18:30PM +0530, Animesh Chaturvedi wrote: > Reposting with subject line VOTE. > > Committers have binding votes for this decision. > > Please respond with your vote: > +1 - Accept the donation and begin the process of bringing this > +enhancement to CloudStack > in via the IP clearance process > +0 - Don't care > -1 - Do not accept the donation > > This vote will remain open for ~72 hours. > > Content Location: http://people.apache.org/~jtomechak > > > > -----Original Message----- > > From: Jessica Tomechak [mailto:[email protected]] > > Sent: Tuesday, January 15, 2013 7:05 PM > > To: [email protected] > > Subject: RE: [IP Clearance] Potential issues > > > > On people.apache.org/~jtomechak, I have posted all my docs related to the > > bug > > items in the IP Clearance list which Animesh provided. > > > > I have made notations in the Doc sub-task of each bug, so that anyone > > reviewing the proposed feature can easily find the documentation. > > > > In addition, I made a note for myself of the doc status of each bug in that > > list, > > and here it is for anyone who is interested! > > > > CLOUDSTACK-774 : > > Code in ACS repo: No > > Functional Spec Posted: Yes > > Community Discussion Done: Yes > > Contribution Size Approx: 5000 lines > > Contributor : Frank > > IP Clearance needed initial recommendation: Yes > > Docs: None exist. This was not announced or supported as a Citrix CP 3.0.6 > > feature. > > > > > > CLOUDSTACK-306 : > > Code in ACS repo: Yes > > Functional Spec Posted: Yes > > Community Discussion Done: Yes in October Contribution Size Approx: 1500 > > lines Contributor : Sheng IP Clearance needed initial recommendation: Yes > > Docs: Already submitted via reviewboard. Link and info in doc subtask. > > > > > > CLOUDSTACK-777/700 : > > Code in ACS repo: Yes > > Functional Spec Posted: No > > Community Discussion Done: Yes > > Contribution Size Approx: 500 lines > > Contributor : Kishan/Jayapal/Rajesh/Murali IP Clearance needed initial > > recommendation: Yes > > Docs: Pending on reviewboard. URL and notations in the doc subtask of the > > bug. > > > > CLOUDSTACK-778/319 : > > Code in ACS repo: No > > Functional Spec Posted: No > > Community Discussion Done: Yes > > Contribution Size Approx: should be small Contributor : Vijayendra IP > > Clearance > > needed initial recommendation: This is a trivial issue so may be no > > Docs: Pending on reviewboard. Info is in the doc subtask of the bug. > > > > CLOUDSTACK-299 : > > Code in ACS repo: UI code is there but backend is not Functional Spec > > Posted: > > Yes Community Discussion Done: Yes Contribution Size Approx: 1400 lines > > Contributor : Jayapal IP Clearance needed initial recommendation: Yes > > Docs: Pending on reviewboard. Link is provided in the description of the > > bug. > > > > CLOUDSTACK-297 : > > Code in ACS repo: No, but posted on review board Functional Spec Posted: Yes > > Community Discussion Done: Yes Contribution Size Approx: 350 lines > > Contributor : Hari IP Clearance needed initial recommendation: > > Docs: One paragraph of new docs on people.a.o. The URL is noted in the doc > > subtask of the bug. http://people.apache.org/~jtomechak/CLOUDSTACK-297/ > > > > > > CLOUDSTACK-197 : > > Code in ACS repo: Multiple patches posted on review board Functional Spec > > Posted: Yes Community Discussion Done: Yes Contribution Size Approx: 3000 > > lines Contributor : Likitha IP Clearance needed initial recommendation: No, > > since incremental patches were posted over a period > > Docs: Believe docs already exist, authored on the community side by > > Sebastien > > G. > > > > CLOUDSTACK-192 : > > Code in ACS repo: No > > Functional Spec Posted: Yes > > Community Discussion Done: Yes, but no consensus reached Contribution Size > > Approx: 1000 lines Contributor : Sanjay IP Clearance needed initial > > recommendation: Yes, if community agrees to feature inclusion > > Docs: On people.a.o. The URL is noted in the doc subtask of the bug. > > http://people.apache.org/~jtomechak/CLOUDSTACK-192/ > > > > > > CLOUDSTACK-304 / 784 : > > Code in ACS repo: Yes > > Functional Spec Posted: Yes > > Community Discussion Done: Yes > > Contribution Size Approx: 600 > > Contributor : Alena > > IP Clearance needed initial recommendation: No, since commits were done > > way back in October over a period of 1 week > > Docs: On people.a.o. The URL is noted in the doc subtask of the bug. > > http://people.apache.org/~jtomechak/CLOUDSTACK-737/ > > > > CLOUDSTACK-265 : > > Code in ACS repo: Yes > > Functional Spec Posted: Yes > > Community Discussion Done: Yes > > Contribution Size Approx: 450 > > Contributor : Murali > > IP Clearance needed initial recommendation: Yes > > Docs: Pending on reviewboard. URL is noted in the doc subtask of the bug. > > > > CLOUDSTACK-737 : > > Code in ACS repo: No > > Functional Spec Posted: Yes > > Community Discussion Done: Yes > > Contribution Size Approx: 2000 > > Contributor : Anthony > > IP Clearance needed initial recommendation: Yes > > Docs: On people.a.o. The URL is noted in the doc subtask of the bug. > > http://people.apache.org/~jtomechak/CLOUDSTACK-737/ > > > > > > CLOUDSTACK-177 : > > Code in ACS repo: Yes > > Functional Spec Posted: Yes > > Community Discussion Done: Yes > > Contribution Size Approx: 300 > > Contributor : Brian > > IP Clearance needed initial recommendation: No, multiple commits over > > several days > > Docs: None were written, probably none needed > > > > CLOUDSTACK-662 : > > Code in ACS repo: Yes > > Functional Spec Posted: Yes > > Community Discussion Done: Yes > > Contribution Size Approx: 500 > > Contributor : Brian > > IP Clearance needed initial recommendation: No, multiple commits over > > several days > > Docs: None were written, probably none needed > > > > CLOUDSTACK-176 : > > Code in ACS repo: Yes > > Functional Spec Posted: Yes > > Community Discussion Done: Yes > > Contribution Size Approx: 200 > > Contributor : Pranav > > IP Clearance needed initial recommendation: No, multiple commits over > > several days > > Docs: None needed > > > > > > CLOUDSTACK-312 : > > Code in ACS repo: Yes > > Functional Spec Posted: Yes > > Community Discussion Done: Yes > > Contribution Size Approx: > > Contributor : Murali > > IP Clearance needed initial recommendation: Potentially yes, multiple > > commits > > in one day > > Docs: Pending on reviewboard. The URL is noted in the Doc subtask of the > > bug. > > > > > > CLOUDSTACK-873 : > > Code in ACS repo: No > > Functional Spec Posted: No > > Community Discussion Done: No > > Contribution Size Approx: Work not started Contributor : Vijayendra/ Kelven > > IP > > Clearance needed initial recommendation: No as work has not started on it > > yet. > > Preliminary investigation done, running into issues with vmware. > > Docs: No existing docs. > > > > > > Jessica Tomechak > > > > -----Original Message----- > > From: Animesh Chaturvedi [mailto:[email protected]] > > Sent: Tuesday, January 15, 2013 12:25 PM > > To: [email protected] > > Subject: RE: [IP Clearance] Potential issues > > > > I am waiting for code to be posted to start the IP clearance process for > > the ones > > identified in my email. Let me send reminders. > > > > > -----Original Message----- > > > From: Chip Childers [mailto:[email protected]] > > > Sent: Tuesday, January 15, 2013 12:19 PM > > > To: [email protected] > > > Subject: Re: [IP Clearance] Potential issues > > > > > > On Mon, Jan 14, 2013 at 6:53 PM, Animesh Chaturvedi > > > <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > To keep the community posted on status on IP clearance. I have > > > > followed up > > > with the contributors of the issues mentioned, as soon as the code is > > > posted publicly, we will start the IP clearance review process. > > > > > > > > Thanks > > > > Animesh > > > > > > Animesh (others) - are there any challenges that you need help with in > > > getting this done?
-- Prasanna.,
