* Dennis Peterson wrote: > On 9/21/10 9:55 PM, Nathan Gibbs wrote: >> >> Now will the REAL C CODERS PLEASE STAND UP! Do it right and show me how >> its done. Better yet, just do it right the first time, and I won't say a >> thing. > > Got your ECR submitted? Has change board seen it, approved it, and slotted > it in the priorities chart? Is it at the top of the chart? Got your design > documents done, identified your metrics for success? Got your functional > tests designed and approved? >
Very good points, all of them, which is why I have said and continue to say that I don't know what I'm doing. > You've coded it so we assume the above is completed. What are the chances > you've done regression testing in all supported environments using all > supported compilers? As stated, I don't know what I'm doing. > Subjected your code for peer review? Done last night. http://www.cmpublishers.com/oss/clamfi.c > Has QA signed off on it? That would be amazing, but I highly doubt that the Quality of my butcher work would stand. > Is your confidence level sufficiently high that you are willing to put your > code out for the public's consumption As stated, Already did. > and you are ready to support it if it breaks stuff? > 0.94.x thats all I'm going to say there. I understand the why, but will never agree with how it was done. If sourcefire can blow up ClamAV installations all over the world, why should I worry about my code doing the same thing? Breakage is a long way off, due to the skill required to get my code into your clamav source. Some people could do it, but not everybody. > If coding were easy anyone could do it, and you've shown it is and anyone > can for very simple projects. That's just the beginning. > Precisely my point. Should I be doing these mods? NO, Absolutely not! Are they that difficult to implement? Apparently not. They should be implemented by someone with far more experience than myself. Last night when I decided to "just for fun" see if I could get the milter to do what I wanted. I thought it would end with me erasing my mangled and nonworking source and unpacking a fresh source from the tarball. I thought I would fail miserably. Imagine my surprise when it worked, especially when you consider that I don't understand half of that code. Now imagine my thoughts about a development team backed by a company that won't implement this. Those guys could do this better than me any day of the week. They could code circles around me, but so far they won't. what does that tell you? -- Sincerely, Nathan Gibbs Systems Administrator Christ Media http://www.cmpublishers.com
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_______________________________________________ Help us build a comprehensive ClamAV guide: visit http://wiki.clamav.net http://www.clamav.net/support/ml
