Tom Shaw wrote:

You really only have two options:

1) bounce the message
2) accept it and set up routing rules for questionable mail.

Jerry,

Not to incite a flame war here but STMP error codes are not built to capture the nuance that Michael is wrestling with.

As I understand it he wants his mailserver to accept the message and quarantine it for analysis and not for later delivery and NOT deliver it to the recipient.

It seems to me perfectly acceptable to return a 5xx as the message has not been accepted for delivery to the recipient.

Tom

I wasn't the OP, just pointing out that option #1 was a bad idea. Personally, I don't see enough virus mail from legit senders that I would want to notify the sender, even with a 550 at SMTP-time. We use scoring to (in theory) avoid quarantining the false positives from third-party signatures.

However, for someone using the milter, 550-and-quarantine seems worthwhile, and certainly doesn't hurt anything -- especially since (I gather) it worked in the past.
_______________________________________________
Help us build a comprehensive ClamAV guide: visit http://wiki.clamav.net
http://www.clamav.net/support/ml

Reply via email to