Just to be clear on my previous email, I encourage all evidence to be gathered, posted and accumulated for proper evaluation of this case. It will prove incredibly useful for all involved as this case moves forward.
It is also proving useful for course development - frankly, I am accumulating files, commentaries, responses and arguments (with appropriate acknowledgments for their efforts at data analysis in this situation) for use in our research ethics course - hope no one minds. If anyone does, please let me know and I'll remove that content, and any reference to that content in this case study. My email was just to be wary of what one says in a publicly posted forum. Tom Hurley