Am 23.05.2012 00:43, schrieb -Eluze:
Urs Liska-3 wrote:
Doc suggestion concerning melisma behaviour.
in
2.1.1 Common notation for vocal music
section
Multiple notes to one syllable
before or after the second example (about slurs) please add something
like:
"Note that phrasing slurs don't affect the creation of melismas."
personally I don't think anybody would expect that phrasing slurs affect
melismata…
Well, through the (Slurs) documentation one is somehow led to believe
slurs and phrasing slurs are practically the same and only separated for
nesting purposes. I was quite surprised to only recently learn that they
for example behave differently at line breaks.
And I have seen (and done) a quite inconsistent use of slurs or phrasing
slurs.
So it would be nice if at this point of the NR it was clearly pointed
out that there _are_ differences for the handling of melismas.
and I'm not sure about where you'd like it - do you mean right before the
section "Predefined commands"?
As said in the OP I'd place it before or after the second example, i.e.
to the paragraph about slurs causing melismas.
Best
Urs
thanks
Eluze
_______________________________________________
bug-lilypond mailing list
bug-lilypond@gnu.org
https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/bug-lilypond
