Jean-Francois sent a minimal example, so I think this is ready for a bug
report.
Thanks,
Carl
------ Forwarded Message
From: "j-f.lucarelli" <j-f.lucare...@espace-midi.com>
Reply-To: <j-f.lucare...@espace-midi.com>
Date: Thu, 15 Jul 2010 13:08:07 -0600
To: Carl Sorensen <c_soren...@byu.edu>
Conversation: Re: Repeat of accidentals after a quotation
Subject: Re: Re: Repeat of accidentals after a quotation
>On 7/14/10 10:22 AM, "Ralph Palmer" <ralphbugl...@gmail.com> wrote:
>
>> Greetings, Jean-François -
>>
>> As a musician, I would not expect the accidental to carry over from the
>> quotation. The quotation is not only in another voice, it's from another
>> part. If you wish to submit a new feature request for a switch, then please
>> submit a minimal example (snippet).
>>
>> Respectfully,
>>
>> Ralph
>>
Dear Ralph,
Sorry for the delay, but it was difficult for me to reduce my big score in a
minimal example.
I present you a very simple score with the problem :
- one measure without quotation
- one measure with quotation, and the sharp wich disappears
- one mesure corrected, with a forced sharp
% begin of the code
\version "2.13.27"
% setup a context for cue notes.
partScoreQuotation = {
\relative c'' {
c8 d e fis
}
}
\addQuote Quotation \partScoreQuotation
% Score without quotation
\new Staff \relative c'' <<
\new Voice {
r2 c4 fis
}>>
% score with quotation - note the sharp wich disappears on the fis in main
voice
\new Staff \relative c'' <<
\new Voice {
\cueDuring #"Quotation" #UP {
r2
}
c4 fis
}>>
% score with quotation and a forced sharp on the fis in main voice
\new Staff \relative c'' <<
\new Voice {
\cueDuring #"Quotation" #UP {
r2
}
c4 fis!
}>>
% end of the code
Normaly, the player don't have attention to the quotation, it's a simple
cue, and the sharp on the fis off the main voice 'll not be played.
The latest notation is thus necessary (with a manual forced sharp) for a
good execution.
I think thus that the quotation must not clear the sharp of the main voice.
Best regards,
Jean-François
Jean-François et Myriam Lucarelli-Marquet
j-f.lucare...@espace-midi.com
http://www.espace-midi.com
------ End of Forwarded Message
_______________________________________________
bug-lilypond mailing list
bug-lilypond@gnu.org
http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/bug-lilypond
