All I can really do with you Mo is disagree. 

Of course the public has a right to make an informed judgement. And all
I can say is that on the blog we have linked to and exposed all sides of
the argument and all the facts (including linking to your Guardian piece
and blog posts - and I suspect more people read it there than would have
if it was published on the blog). Anyone who is a regular reader of the
blog and interested in this issue would be well informed.

Again its not about the BBC not being honest. It's about the fact that
some people disagree with the BBC's position. But it's a honest
position, honestly held.

-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected]
[mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Mo McRoberts
Sent: 15 June 2010 23:47
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [backstage] Freeview HD Content Management


On 15-Jun-2010, at 22:41, Nick Reynolds-FM&T wrote:

> The BBC has made its position quite clear on the blog - not once but 
> several times. We have been straight about it as you can see from 
> these blog posts, not just recently but as far back as April last year

> (see Danielle Nagler's post in the list below) - so the idea that we 
> didn't want to talk about this is false:

well, yes. the *position* was very clear. the facts - that is, what was
being proposed and the nitty-gritty of how it would actually affect
people - weren't, as evidenced by the many questions which went
unanswered in the blog comments.

Tom Watson's blog post contained inaccuracies because he was
interpreting a very technical industry document without background
knowledge - which was what everybody else (myself included) had to do in
order to figure out what it was that was actually being proposed (how
else are people supposed to know what they're dealing with?)

the _position_ took priority over the facts. the BBC was very effective
at communicating the position. it was abysmal at communicating the
facts. the closest it came was Danielle's post back in April last year
(which I linked to earlier in this thread - I was very aware of it!),
and even that was rather heavy on the PR, and took some flak at the time
for it.

> I have worked hard to get the BBC to engage with you and in my view 
> bearing in mind the obvious sensitivities we have done this well. Even

> I though we couldn't publish your blog post I spent time trying to get

> it published in other places, encouraged you to do so and I was 
> pleased when it was.


Don't get me wrong, I do very much appreciate your efforts - please
don't take this as a personal criticism, because it's not, at all - in
no small part because it's not *your* job to translate engineering terms
into the actual effects. I'm not sure what the sensitivities are - does
the public not have a right to make an informed judgement given the
facts of it?

> And I'm saddened that you use the word "disgraceful" in your email 
> below. I believe the BBC has communicated this as well as we can.

I'm sorry you're saddened, but believe me, the BBC (not "you" singular),
could have done a lot better better. Communication on this was shoddy
and haphazard, it - with the exception of Danielle's post - reeked of
damage-limitation, missed out half of the stuff that people would
naturally want to know, and you weren't able to find out the answer to.
In fact, you had asked some of same questions, because you didn't know
the answer either. I know for a fact, though, that lots of the people
within the BBC who were involved in creating this whole thing would have
known the answers, because if you're an expert in DVB, it's actually
pretty basic stuff! (don't forget, this had already been implemented
once already, and the BBC, via the DTG and DTLA, were talking to
receiver manufacturers to ensure they were doing the right thing).

so, to be brutally honest, if there's something you couldn't be more
wrong about in this whole affair, it's this. the BBC wasn't particularly
honest - it didn't lie, but it was a very very long way away from the
whole truth - and I think it's unfortunate that you've been taken along
for the ride. I think *you*, not to mention everybody else, deserve
better than that, even if we ultimately disagree about whether the
actual proposal is a good or a bad thing.

M.
-
Sent via the backstage.bbc.co.uk discussion group.  To unsubscribe,
please visit
http://backstage.bbc.co.uk/archives/2005/01/mailing_list.html.
Unofficial list archive:
http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/

-
Sent via the backstage.bbc.co.uk discussion group.  To unsubscribe, please 
visit http://backstage.bbc.co.uk/archives/2005/01/mailing_list.html.  
Unofficial list archive: http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/

Reply via email to