Mo, 

The BBC has made its position quite clear on the blog - not once but
several times. We have been straight about it as you can see from these
blog posts, not just recently but as far back as April last year (see
Danielle Nagler's post in the list below) - so the idea that we didn't
want to talk about this is false:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/bbcinternet/2009/04/welcome_to_some_new_initi
als_d.html

http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/bbcinternet/2009/09/freeview_hd_copy_protecti
on_up.html

http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/bbcinternet/2009/10/freeview_hd_copy_protecti
on_a.html

http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/bbcinternet/2010/01/freeview_hd_content_manag
ement.html

Tom Watson's original blog post contained inaccuracies as he himself
subsequently admitted and corrected.

As is often the case when the BBC takes a position that people disagree
with they then accuse the BBC of not being straight with them. We are
being straight but I'm afraid we can't give you exactly what you want.
There's no conspiracy or cover up we just disagree.

I have worked hard to get the BBC to engage with you and in my view
bearing in mind the obvious sensitivities we have done this well. Even I
though we couldn't publish your blog post I spent time trying to get it
published in other places, encouraged you to do so and I was pleased
when it was.

And I'm saddened that you use the word "disgraceful" in your email
below. I believe the BBC has communicated this as well as we can.  

-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected]
[mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Mo McRoberts
Sent: 15 June 2010 22:14
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [backstage] Freeview HD Content Management

right,

I'm going to level with you all:

I'm tired. very tired. I'm juggling a day-job building e-commerce
websites with a hobby helping to build some very very cool things, and
I've put an awful lot of time and effort into questioning, gaining
understanding of and explaining this whole Freeview HD copy-protection
debacle. I don't think I've been especially unclear, or got caught up in
rhetoric and emotion to any a great extent, and I've done my best to try
to answer questions and concerns and everything else to the best of my
knowledge. now, it's true that my knowledge of DVB internals isn't the
best in the world: the people for whom that holds true work for the BBC
and so can't really comment too much. but, I've taken what I do know and
tried to put it into plain English as much as I possibly can, and as far
as I can see much of this whole thing is rather cut-and-dried.

now, to be clear, this scheme hasn't particularly irritated me. in all
honesty, it was to be expected to an extent. there are aspects of it
which *have* annoyed me, but not to the point of getting angry about it
(the last time that happened, I spent all a whole day adding signatures
to the bottom of an open letter...)

what _has_ irritated to me, however, is the fact that nobody
representing the BBC will be straight about it. everything has to be
dressed up to make it look appealing (especially where it isn't), which
makes it a whole lot worse if it's principally motivated by _other_
Freeview HD broadcasters. the whole approach to it was not one of
informing the public in a fair and impartial manner, but of public
relations.

now, I wrote this article, originally for the BBC Internet Blog, but it
was declined (as the BBC had already made their position clear and
wanted nothing which might detract from it), and luckily I managed to
persuade the Guardian to run it instead:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2010/apr/01/bbc-hd-consultation-hdmi

this was an article that I wrote deliberately (given its target outlet)
to avoid speculation, half-truths, paranoia, cynicism or knee-jerk,
sticking as much as humanly possible to the facts. if anything, I
probably gave the BBC the benefit of the doubt a little more than I
should! now, I can understand that it was declined for publication.
after all, at that point, a guest post from a non-staffer was pretty
unprecedented. but that's besides the point: why was it necessary for me
to write that post in the first place?

the method of engagement which the BBC employed - principally the BBC
Internet blog (and only _after_ Cory Doctorow and Tom Watson drew
attention to the proposal which had been quietly submitted to Ofcom
without any form of public statement by the BBC) - glossed over the
stuff that was in there, and yet those were the things people wanted to
know most of all.

so, all in all, I'm disappointed by the BBC. not for pushing this
through per se, but for its approach to it, which has been nothing short
of disgraceful. for the record, Nick, although I *disagree* with you on
some things, I think you've done as good a job as you could have done
with this whole thing - I do think it was ridiculous that you were left
to field questions, though (questions which would never have arisen had
the BBC been upfront and honest with everybody in the first place).

I've made my position on the actual scheme quite clear, so I'm going to
stop now. most of us on here are as far as I know (save for some
quibbles over minor details and loopholes) of *broadly* the same
opinion, though depending on your perspective your position might vary
from "argh!" to "worthless waste of everybody's time" (or more likely,
somewhere in between). there are some who disagree, who think the
short-term gain is worth the long-term loss, and I can't do anything but
agree to disagree. my colours have been nailed to the mast, and I'm not
going to continue re-stating the facts in as many different ways as I
can muster in order to answer the same points over and over again.

as I said, I have better things to be doing with my time. I'm not going
anywhere, and I'll still be reading this thread, but I don't honestly
have the energy to keep replying to anything but purely technical stuff
in relation to this.

I really am very tired.

M.


-
Sent via the backstage.bbc.co.uk discussion group.  To unsubscribe,
please visit
http://backstage.bbc.co.uk/archives/2005/01/mailing_list.html.
Unofficial list archive:
http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/

-
Sent via the backstage.bbc.co.uk discussion group.  To unsubscribe, please 
visit http://backstage.bbc.co.uk/archives/2005/01/mailing_list.html.  
Unofficial list archive: http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/

Reply via email to