> Jahanzeb, do you know the tragedy of being rahman fan (i don't know for all)??? Whoever knows that you are a Rahman fan.....they will rush to you complaining that these Rahman songs are not good.....
well said man, i agree with you. but unfortunately i think with a song such as shano shano (and in an album like yuvvraaj) ARR has given these people quite an excuse to rush us (ARR fans) and complain. --- In [email protected], "Arijit Debnath" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > I am not talking about any particular person who didn't or did like all the > above songs from the 1st hearing (like you)...we are not discussing > individual...am telling from my past experience...what my > freinds/relatives/known person told me after 1st hearing.... but later all > of them realized that those are great song... > > Jahanzeb, do you know the tragedy of being rahman fan (i don't know for > all)??? Whoever knows that you are a Rahman fan.....they will rush to you > complaining that these Rahman songs are not good...he lost touch...why still > u're listening to them???? So from friend circle/relative circle I got the > 1st feedback...which I got used to...also the same folks tell me after 6 > months to 1 yr...great songs in Dilse/Guru/Swadesh/RDB..and the lsit will go > on..... > > Hope you undersatnd... > > Arijit > > > > 2008/10/20 Jahanzeb Farooq <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > > i dont think shano should be compared to these songs. only one of the > > five songs you mentioned (Rukmani rukmani) i found little odd in the > > first hearing. all the rest i loved instantly or after some time. but > > shano is the song which when i heard the first time my feelings were > > "what the hell is this?" and "what is wrong with ARR?", and i skipped > > it in anger and disappointment. later i gave it second chance and now > > at least i dont skip it. > > but we shall remember that only we, the fans of ARR, will give it > > second chance, because we are his fans and because we know his music > > grow, a common man will never do it, he will simply skip it and will > > never listen it again and will only ridicule what went wrong with ARR. > > and he will be right because ARR never composed such a weak song > > before and that too for such a big movie as yuvvraaj. > > i will soon ask some of my non-ARR-fan friends to listen shano shano > > and will see if my prediction is correct or not. > > > > --- In [email protected] <arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com>, > > "Arijit Debnath" <arijit741@> > > wrote: > > > > > > > > Shano shano is getting critised everday in this forum.... ok I am > > taking > > > this in a positive way thinking that Rahman may compose same genre > > song with > > > more vibrant way....instead of discarding these kind of rhythmic > > scores. > > > > > > But I thing this is one of the greatest song which will create great > > > history.... It has got some strange tune built inside which is > > compelling to > > > go to floor every time...same reaction I got in the song > > "Maramkothiye" from > > > Ah Aha... > > > > > > Shano Shano is taking me in trance while the female voice is > > rendering a > > > beatiful tune. > > > > > > I heard the same kind of critisism for "Rukmani Rukmani", "Humba > > Humba", to > > > some extent "Chaiyan Chaiyan" (voice doesn'r suit Sahrukh etc), and > > more > > > recently "Pappu" and "Taxi"....all these songs proved Rahman's > > capability to > > > get everyone on the dance floor.... all these tunes has something > > strange in > > > them...one can't sit idle listening to these songs I believe.... if > > that is > > > not the case I'm insane.... > > > > > > Arijit > > > > > > > > > >
