> On May 11, 2026, at 4:07 PM, Trigon via agora-business > <[email protected]> wrote: > On 5/11/26 12:46 PM, msh210 via agora-business wrote: >> My Agoran birthday has occurred in the last fifteen days. [Cf. CFJ 3873.] > > Well, this is a bit frustrating. I recall when drafting this rule asking the > Agoran public whether or not "anniversary" was strict enough to make a > player's Agoran birthday only occur in the years following the registration > and everyone more or less agreed. It was under this same assumption that I > wrote the birthday scoring rule. I am therefore a bit surprised to see this > judgement. > > I will obviously award both the welcome package and the birthday when I am > doing my Numerator pass, but two birthday scores is not what I intended with > this provision. > > I submit the following proposal: > > Title: No double scores for new players > AI: 1 > > Amend rule 2585, Birthday Gifts, by adding after the text "by this method for > that instance of eir Agoran Birthday" the text "and provided that that > instance of eir Agoran Birthday is not eir date of first registration" > > -- > Trigon > > Popular Polygon and Treasuror Extraordinaire
Now is probably a good time to inform you that I also saw this same ruling in the FLR and scored my birthday on April 1st: https://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/msg48787.html I believe that technically this means you violated Rule 2713, although the statute of limitations means you're safe from investigation. - Galle
