I favor this case, because I'd find it nice to do. I'd just like to judge something and this seems interesting.
On Tue, Mar 5, 2024 at 5:38 AM Aris via agora-business < agora-busin...@agoranomic.org> wrote: > On Mon, Mar 4, 2024 at 8:33 PM Rowan Evans via agora-business < > agora-busin...@agoranomic.org> wrote: > > > I register as LegallyBearded > > > > I grant myself 52 welcome packages, each containing 1 stamp. > > > > I pay 51 stamps of the same type to gain (51-1)*2 = 100 radiance. > > > > I observe that my radiance is 100, and win. > > > > ---- > > CFJ > > Does "granting" an asset cause it to be received? > > > > Brief explanation. By rule 2499: Any player CAN, by announcement, grant a > > Welcome Package to any player if the grantee has neither received one > since > > e last registered nor in the last 30 days. > > > > By rule 2577: Granting an asset causes it to be "created in that entity's > > possession". I take this to be meaningfully different from "receiving" an > > asset, because granting is distinguished from the "transfer" of an asset > in > > this same rule. > > > > And as a point of interest: most other references to "receiving" in the > > rules require the item to be sent. > > > > FOR: When you create an item in your own possession, it hardly makes > sense > > to say you received it. If I make a paper plane, can I say I received it? > > From where? Doesn't make sense in plain English. > > AGAINST: This scam ignores the intent of the clause it's trying to get > > around. > > > > Erm... that CFJ doesn't do what you want it to. CFJs are supposed to be > statements, not questions, and interpreting something out of context is > different from interpreting it in context. > > I CFJ, barring LegallyBearded: In the above message, LegallyBearded > successfully granted emself 52 welcome packages. > > -Aris >
