On 5/22/2020 7:22 AM, nch via agora-discussion wrote: > I know I said I didn't want to get bogged down in design choice debates but > since the auction portion has to be rewritten (and it looks like the rewrite > might be more complex than I thought), I wanted to get some feedback. > > As far as I see it, there's two main options right now: > > 1) Rewrite the auction [the faithful option] > > 2) Remove it, leaving no way to get victory cards until a new proposal is > passed [the easier option] > > I do have ideas for alternatives, but I'd rather not switch to one in the > middle of trying to get this passed. Thoughts? >
Alexis had an auction re-write proposal last month that had some good stuff in it (though it also needed lots of work). I was thinking of working on that as a starting point sometime soon (it would make auctions a lot cleaner in general) could try to get to that sooner? Since VPs are relatively independent I'd either leave it out, or come up with a very simple method to get us going (e.g. "In each Agoran week the Treasuror CAN once, and SHALL, randomly select a player who wasn't selected in the previous week, and grant em a victory card by announcement." - that's a pretty complete method?) in a standalone rule that can be replaced easily? -G.
