On 1/25/20 8:32 PM, Alexis Hunt via agora-discussion wrote:
> Amend Rule 2125 (Regulated Actions) to read:
> {
> An action is regulated by a body of law if (1) its performance is
> limited, allowed, enabled, or permitted by that body of law; (2) that
> body of law describes the circumstances under which it would succeed
> or fail; or (3) it would, as part of its effect, modify information
> for which some person bound by that body of law is required, by that
> body of law, to be a recordkeepor.
>
> If a body of law regulates an action, then to the extent that doing so
> is within its scope, that body of law prevents the action from being
> performed except as described within it, including by limiting the
> methods to perform that action to those specified within it. A body of
> law does not proscribed any action which it does not regulate.
> }
>
> [I'm sad about losing the SHALL NOT there. Violating that would surely
> have been one of the great Agoran crimes, along with failing to
> carefully consider the consequences of not reading the ruleset during
> RtRW.]This came up a while back in CFJ 3737. I asked whether a contract prohibiting an action (in that case, breathing) caused that action to become a Regulated Action. The H. Judge Trigon issued a judgement, and omd then Pointed eir Finger at Trigon for "interpreting the Rules so as to proscribe unregulated actions". Sadly, the Finger-point went unresolved. -- Jason Cobb
