On 1/12/2020 9:10 PM, omd via agora-discussion wrote: > On Sun, Jan 12, 2020 at 8:46 PM Kerim Aydin via agora-business > <agora-busin...@agoranomic.org> wrote: >> Create a Power=2 Rule, "Sacrifice", with the following text: >> >> The Shogun CAN sacrifice eir honour by publishing a valid Notice >> of Honour that decreases eir own honour by one, while in the >> same message clearly specifying a decision to adopt a proposal >> that is in its voting period. The Shogun's voting strength is >> on that decision is increased to its maximum possible within the > > Duplicate "is". > >> rules, provided the option identified on eir valid ballot on the >> decision is AGAINST. >> >> [an emergency proposal stop, via a sacrifice of honour.] > > What happens if you vote AGAINST, sacrifice your honor, then change > your vote to FOR? The wording makes it seem like the voting strength > increase happens at the time of the sacrifice, which would imply that > the check for a valid AGAINST ballot also happens at that time.
Shoot. I was being really, really conscious of avoiding that ambiguity but looks like I failed. Will try again. > Also, the maximum possible strength is less than twice the default > strength, so this seems underpowered. Yeah, I wanted to keep it power-2 though, I thought mucking with the max would be more controversial. At least, since it only works on AGAINST votes, its power magnifies as the power of the proposal increases. -G.
