I find CFJ 3561 TRUE. I concur with the caller's arguments that while he was allowed to destroy the stamps, he was not capable of destroying the stamps. ---- Publius Scribonius Scholasticus p.scribonius.scholasti...@gmail.com
> On Sep 27, 2017, at 7:02 PM, Kerim Aydin <ke...@u.washington.edu> wrote: > > > > (Apologies for missing this one, was called just before Arbitor changeover) > > I hereby assign the following CFJ to Publius Scribonius Scholasticus: > > > ============================== CFJ 3561 ============================== > > In the above-quoted message, Gaelan destroyed exactly zero stamps. > > ======================================================================== > > Caller: o > > ======================================================================== > > History: > > Called by o: 07 Sep 2017 > > ======================================================================== > > Caller's Arguments: > > Rule 2498 (“Economic Wins”) states, in part: > >> Players MAY, by announcement, destroy a Stamp and cause Agora to >> transfer the Stamp Value, in shinies, to em. > > Under rule 2125 (“Regulated Actions”), destroying Stamps is restricted: > >> An action is restricted if: >> ... >> (3) the action would, as part of its effect, modify information for >> which some player is required to be a recordkeepor. > > The recordkeepor of Stamps is, under rule 2498 (“Stamps”), the Secretary. > > Therefore, it is not possible to destroy stamps through any mechanism > described in rule 2498. Rule 2166 (“Assets”) does provide a mechanism > for destroying stamps: > >> An asset generally CAN be destroyed by its owner by announcement, >> subject to modification by its backing document. > > This power is not restricted by the backing document for stamps, but > Gaelen did not own any stamps at that time. > > Therefore, no stamps were destroyed by Gaelan’s actions. > > ======================================================================== > > Caller's Evidence: > > On Sep 7, 2017, at 3:14 AM, Gaelan Steele <g...@canishe.com> wrote: > >> OK, I’m just gonna do the scam properly so I can stop keeping secrets >> and whatnot. >> >> For each player by reverse order of first registration, I destroy eir >> stamps one at a time, causing Agora to give me the stamp value in >> shinies for each, until Agora can no longer afford to do so. >> >> That was your mistake, cuddle—I didn’t realize the exact numbers at >> the time of my first message, but in fact VJ’s reward brought Agora’s >> shinies below 36 (9 stamps in existence * 4 per stamp), which meant >> that cuddle’s most recent attempt failed because he didn’t specify >> which stamps e wanted to remain. >> >> If I successfully destroyed at least one stamp above, I give >> CuddleBeam a Consolation Prize of 10 shinies. I am happy to provide >> some of my stolen shinies to ensure the proper functioning of the >> game. >> >> Gaelan > > ======================================================================== >
signature.asc
Description: Message signed with OpenPGP using GPGMail
