I checked the proposal history. There has been a time where Switches had
higher Power than Offices, making its switch not a switch, ergo, there have
been no Officeholders since (Possibly?).

Of course this would screw over a lot of things, would it be so, but
everything we're doing wouldn't actually matter if everything has been
bogus since.

Proto CFJ "After Proposal 5111 got enacted, there have been no
Officeholders."

Gratuitous Arguments:
- "Switches" (or at least the modern implementation of it, as it wasn't
there before) were Created by Proposal 5111 (Murphy), 2 August 2007. You
can see that proposal here:
http://www.mail-archive.com/agora-official@agoranomic.org/msg08096.html,
and it says:

Create a rule titled "Switches" with Power 2 and this text:

"A type of switch is a property that the rules define as a switch, and
specify the following: (...)
2. One or more possible values for instances of that switch, *exactly one
of which is designated as the default. *No other values are possible for
instances of that switch."

- The Power of the Offices rule changed from 1 to 2 by Proposal 5133
(Zefram), 13 August 2007.

- Our Anti-Ossification protection didn't exist until Proposal 5536
(Murphy), 7 June 2008, which added:

"In the interest of safeguarding Agora's nomic-ness, if a change to the
gamestate would otherwise make it IMPOSSIBLE to make arbitrary rule changes
and/or adopt arbitrary proposals within a four-week period by any
combinations of actions by players, then that change is canceled and does
not occur, any rule to the contrary notwithstanding."

- From the 2nd of August onwards, we have been in a state were there have
been no Officeholders, because Switches need a default, and Officeholders
had none, so it wasn't a switch. Proposal 5133, which would've solved the
problem, actually hasn't been enacted - because there need to be Office(s)
to do so (The Assesor, Promotor, etc). We didn't have the Anti-Ossification
rules to prevent this either (and if they did, then Proposal 5111 would've
actually never done anything, and we have never actually had our modern
Switches)

Non-Proposal (and Non-Office dependent rule-changes in general, really)
Rule-changes aside, the Ruleset hasn't actually changed since the 2nd of
August 2007.

Reply via email to