On 09/30/2010 09:14 PM, Ed Murphy wrote:
coppro wrote:
On 09/30/2010 07:28 AM, Alex Smith wrote:
I CFJ on the statement "At some time in the past, Keba was the Speaker",
barring Wooble.
Arguments: Rule 2315 only allows initialisation the List of Succession
"as soon as possible after this proposal takes effect"; unfortunately,
rule 2315 is not a proposal, so this never happened. Thus, as far as I
can tell the List of Succession was never initially initalised.
I'm not entirely sure what knock-on effects this has/had, or how much
has ratified away by now; luckily it didn't happen so long ago that it's
going to be impossible to calculate the resulting effects. I'd
appreciate judicial input on whether there actually was a mistake,
though, before trying to figure out what effects it had.
TRUE; the IADoP's report has self-ratified.
Herald's, but yeah, if the list self-ratified (per Rule 2314) at any
point then the first paragraph of Rule 2315 is no longer relevant.
The IADoP reports on the Speaker; the Herald's report on the list has
also self-ratified, but that is not directly related to the inquiry.
-coppro
