On Thu, 2009-04-09 at 14:25 -0500, comex wrote:
> On Thu, Apr 9, 2009 at 1:52 PM, Alex Smith <ais...@bham.ac.uk> wrote:
> > That would imply that a player could remove all their Rests by spending
> > just 2 Notes. After all, you CAN destroy a Rest by spending 2 Notes. So
> > your Note spend destroys as many Rests as you want...
> 
> I don't see what your argument is there.  If we treat that in terms of
> the effect of announcements, I am announcing that I spend two notes to
> destroy a Rest.  The assets rule makes such an announcement effective,
> with or without the 'destroy a Rest' bit; the Rests rule says that
> when I announce that I am spending two notes 'to destroy a
> Rest'==>'for the purpose of destroying a Rest', the announcement does
> in fact destroy one of my Rests, but it's implied that an announcement
> can only have one such purpose.  So I can't destroy multiple rests, or
> spend C C to destroy a rest as well as giving ehird a C note, etc.
> because I have to have exactly one purpose for the destruction.  But
> the contests rule does not say I award points 'for a particular
> contest' or 'to be an award for a particular contest', only that I
> award points up to the total.  An announcement that I award points
> thus can satisfy that condition for multiple contests.
> 
> (By the way, I'm not sure why agora.qoid.us is down, I'll try to get
> it up when I get back and publish conductor/rulekeepor reports etc.)

Hmm... suppose the Scorekeepor is a contestmaster, and e rewards another
contestmaster due to monthly rewards. Does that count against the points
limit of eir contest?

-- 
ais523

Reply via email to