Ed Murphy wrote: > CFJ: Proposal 6122 has taken effect. > > Caller's arguments: Per Rule 2034(c) as amended by Proposal 6139, the > resolution of Proposals 6121 through 6139 constituted a self-ratifying > claim that Proposal 6122 has not been prevented from taking effect.
Gratuitous arguments: The resolution of those proposals does constitute such a claim, however, you cannot prevent something that would never have happened in the first instance (Otherwise, I just prevented you from being attacked by a lion. You're welcome). Since the only means by which a proposal can take effect is by adoption, and it was not adopted, the proposal never would have taken effect, and therefore cannot have been prevented.
