On Thu, 8 Jan 2009, Alex Smith wrote: > I call for judgement on the statement {{{If a rule were created with the > text {{Wooble SHALL NOT Dance a Powerful Dance. Neither sentence of this > rule has an effect.}}, then it would be ILLEGAL for Wooble to Dance a > Powerful Dance.}}}
Trivial refutation option: Any questions on a hypothetical a future ruleset must take into account multiple possible states of other future rules of which we know nothing, any one of which might overrule this entirely. UNDETERMINED. (no, I know it's not the only option but I think it's a justified one if you're bored of these trivial attempts). -G.