On Sat, 2008-10-18 at 14:25 -0700, Kerim Aydin wrote: > I agree to the following pledge, called HAL: > > 1. By pledge of Goethe, HAL is a biological organism that can communicate > in English. Goethe may act on behalf of HAL by announcement. Goethe > may terminate HAL by announcement. > > On behalf of HAL, I announce that HAL registers. > > I CFJ on the following: HAL is a first-class player. > This pledge is obviously self-contradictory. If Goethe could terminate HAL by announcement, e could remove eir right to call CFJs. By rule 101, this is obviously impossible.
Also, HAL is not party to that pledge, so you can't Mousetrap em like that. (Rule 101 would stop you doing so.) Therefore, you can't act on behalf of em. Therefore, obviously FALSE, even if your point is conceded. -- ais523
