[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote on 01/10/2008 08:07:37 PM: > I finaly found the cause of the error.... > > Since my disks are mounted in a cassette with four in each I had to > disconnect all cables to them to replace the crashed disk. > > When re-attaching the cables I reversed the order of them by > accident. In my early tests this was not a problem since zfs > identified the disks anyway, regardless on what controller the disk > was connected to (as long as the controllers was listed for the pool). > > What happened was some kind of an race condition(?). Since the disk > on controller c2d0 crashed it was listed as corrupt. But since I > connected an healthy disk (and already an member of the pool (from > controller c3d1)) to c2d0 instead of the new one that should > originally replace the crashed disk my problem developed. > > Zfs therefor listed the original c2d0 disk as faulty but the > realized that there was an healthy disk on c2d0, i.e. c2d0 was both > ok and faulty!! This means that any command acting on c2d0 would not > succeed due to both disks listed as c2d0. > > In this condition there seems to exist no way of telling zfs to > discard the faulty disk entry since both are assigned the name c2d0 > and is/was connected to the same controller. > > My resolution was (after many hours of moving disks and reboots to > find the error) to make sure that only the new (not yet assigned) > disk was connected to c2d0 and none of the other disks that already > was assigned to the pool. > > I must consider this to be an bug that you can't remove/clear this > kind of error in zfs to be able to repair your pool. > > Due to all my efforts it seems that my pool became corrupted in the > end (probably due to scrubbing and resilver) so I have some hours > to kill, restoring my data...... >
I am confused, I was under the impression that zfs actually checks the zfs labels on the disks to make sure they are correct when mounting (to avoid disk rename issues exactly like above)? Is this an edge case that has not been accounted for or am I misunderstanding the disk label/name schematics? -Wade _______________________________________________ zfs-discuss mailing list zfs-discuss@opensolaris.org http://mail.opensolaris.org/mailman/listinfo/zfs-discuss
