Dear Sir or Madam,
in a publically funded project we are currently preparing a scientific
study that investigates the process model in open source projects in
order to identify common best practices and classify the processes.
That is why we are running a survey among some prominent open source
projects asking for development and decision making processes. I would
be very grateful if one or two of you could answer the questions below
(usually by simply "checking"). It would be great if you could return
your answers by March 25, 2003. I can guarantee that your answers will
be handled absolutely confidentially, will be used for scientific
research only, and will be published exclusively as statistical results.
Many thanks in advance. If you are interested, I can send you the
analysis of this survey. In case of any questions, do not hesitate to
contact me.
Kind regards,
Thomas Wieland
------------------------------------------------------------------
Prof. Dr. Thomas Wieland
Department of Electrical Engineering & Computer Science
University of Applied Sciences Coburg
Friedrich-Streib-Str. 2 Phone: +49 (9561) 317-392
D-96450 Coburg Fax: +49 (9561) 317-171
Germany E-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
------------------------------------------------------------------
Questionnaire on Open Source Development Processes
March 15, 2003
With this questionnaire we want to find out more about the processes
that are in use for the development of open source products. In a
scientific study, we are trying to identify common best practices and
classify the processes. Thus we would be grateful if you could answer
the following questions.
1 Project involvement
For the following questions, please focus on the project that you
are most familiar with. This is:
_______________________________________________________________
2 Size of project
How many developers are involved in your project?
___________________
>From how many countries are the developers?
_______________________
How many lines of code does the project comprise now?
___________________
When was the project started?
___________________
3 Role of yourself
Check which role(s) applies best to you (no more than 3)
o Patron: initiates a project, provides infrastructure and
ideas
o Project coordinator: person (or representative of
organization) that initiated and supervises the project
o Steering committee member
o Committer: a developer who regularly contributes to the
project, makes check-ins to the repository and participates
in design and feature decisions
o Partner: gives feedback or contributes his own software as
building block
o System integrator: uses the software and integrates it
into larger systems
o Friend: uses the software and gives feedback (bug reports
etc.), but does not develop actively
o User: person who just uses the software and does not care
about development
o Other (please specify):
______________________________________________
4 Motivation
What did you and other motivate to participate in the project?
(Check all that apply)
o It's a famous project (I like the idea)
o It uses/creates cool technology
o It's about my fields of interest
o I want to get famous through it
o I want to give value back for the great open source
software I got
o The software is useful for almost everybody
o Renowned developers are working in it
o Big companies back it
o Can be easily adapted to personal needs/environment
o My company pays me for participating
o I offer paid consulting services based on my know-how from
the project
o Other:
___________________________________________________________
5 Membership in steering committee
If your project has a steering committee, how are members selected
for it?
o By appointment of the project coordinator
o By appointment of the steering committee
o By election among all committers
o By application of prospective member
o By appointment of a company who backs/supports the project
o Other (please specify):
_________________________________________
6 Process of the project
Is your project following a standard process?
o Rational Unified Process (RUP)
o Catalysis
o Extreme Programming
o Agile Development
o Other (please specifiy):
_________________________________________
If no, has there been a decision not to follow a process?
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
7 Project phases
Are you dividing your project into iterations and phases
(analysis, design, implement, test, release)?
o Well-defined iterations with classical phases
o Each release is an iteration, phases are overlapping
slightly
o No iterations, phases are largely overlapping, everything
is done in parallel
o Other (please specifiy):
_________________________________________
Comments:
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
8 Project management elements
Please check which tasks are fulfilled in your project in an
organized and repeated way, which of these elements do you consider
to be extraordinarily important and which ones, in your opinion,
should be used at all or more extensively.
Management Element Fulfilled Very Should be
in my important used
project
Requirements management o o o
Use case management o o o
Version management o o o
Quality assurance/review o o o
process
Test management o o o
Personalization/localizati o o o
on management
Release management o o o
Risk management o o o
Comments:
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
9 Tool support
Which tools are you using for the following tasks:
o Collecting, organizing, and tracking requirements :
_______________________________________________________________
o Collecting, describing, and tracking use cases:
_______________________________________________________________
o Software design:
_______________________________________________________________
o Configuration management:
_______________________________________________________________
o Version management:
_______________________________________________________________
o Testing:
_______________________________________________________________
o Localization:
_______________________________________________________________
o Software packaging:
_______________________________________________________________
o CRM (contact to users):
_______________________________________________________________
o Bug tracing:
_______________________________________________________________
o Project management:
_______________________________________________________________
o Others (please specify name and purpose):
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
Are there situations where you wish to have better tool support?
(Has your project thought about developing its own tools?)
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
10 Task assignment
How do you specify the tasks that need to be done next and how
do you assign them to the project members?
o The project coordinator defines the tasks
o The steering committee defines the tasks
o The tasks are suggested by project members (steering
committee, project coordinator, committers) in common
communication
o The project coordinator assigns the tasks
o The steering committee assigns the tasks
o The tasks are assigned by agreement in common
communication
o The defined tasks can be picked by any volunteer
o Other/Comments:
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
11 Configurable items
Which items do you manage by your configuration management system?
Please check all that apply.
o Source code (incl. scripts, makefiles etc.)
o Object code (e.g. of libraries)
o Tools (development tools, code generating tools)
o Distributable documents (Readmes, installation
instructions)
o Entire project documentation (incl. manuals etc.)
o All files produced and exchanged within the project
o Other:
____________________________________________________________
12 Access to configuration repository
Which statements about access restrictions of the configuration
repository apply to your project?
o Everybody is granted anonymous read access
o Everybody is granted personalized read access
o Everybody is allowed to check in new files
o Everybody is allowed to check in changed files
o Only accredited committers are allowed to check in changed
and new files
o Only minor patches may be checked in by committers, major
changes only by project coordinator
o Only the project coordinator is allowed to check in
changed and new files
o Strict locking is used on the repository so that only one
developer at a time can make changes
o Our repository uses concurrent locking allowing
simultaneous development
o Other:
____________________________________________________________
13 Definition of interfaces
How do you define the interfaces between the modules of your software?
o Decision of project coordinator
o Decision of steering committee
o Coordination of committers over mailing list
o Each committer is responsible for the interfaces of his
own module, the others have to use it
o Other:
____________________________________________________________
Comments:
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
14 Decision making in general
How do you make decisions (about adding new features, freezing
for release, architecture etc.)?
o Project coordinator decides alone
o Steering committee decides in consensus
o Steering committee decides by voting
o All committers decide by voting
o Committers make proposals on mailing list and get feedback
o New features are added by the individual committer
whenever they are ready
o Other:
____________________________________________________________
Comments:
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
15 Communication
What are your most important communication means in the project,
especially for decision making?
o General mailing list
o Steering committee mailing list (inner circle)
o Newsgroup (usenet, web-based)
o Community web site
o Restricted part of web site
o Phone (conferences)
o Personal meetings
o Other (please specify):
_______________________________________________
Comments:
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
16 Strengths of your process
Which are the most important strengths of your project process
in your opinion (please check no more than 3)?
o Initial build is enhanced incrementally through a series
of regular iterations
o Managing as many design, build, and testing activities as
possible in parallel (overlapping iterations)
o Development is decentralized
o Authority and responsibility are awarded to those who
demonstrate the most competence
o Communication among participants in an open-source project
is asynchronous
o Planning is informal (rarely concrete plans or visions,
just singular ideas)
o Product architectures in open-source projects are highly
modular
o Other (please specify):
_______________________________________________
Comments:
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
17 Weaknesses of your process
Which are the most important weaknesses of your project process
in your opinion (please check no more than 3)?
o Prototyping is highly dependent on the expertise of the
originator
o Rapid evolution by iterative and incremental enhancement,
eroding the design
o Concurrency increases the overhead
o Peer review cannot identify high-level architectural flaws
or finding obscure flaws
o Domain experts writing code introduce feature creep
o Reinvention due to decentralisation
o Personal conflicts overshadow discussion about technical
solutions
o Disputes over code acceptance sometimes escalate
o Asynchronous communication is unmanageable.
o Informal planning makes forecasting virtually impossible
o Different levels of participation installs a management
hierarchy that incurs overhead
o Process does not produce adequate documentation
o Other (please specify):
_______________________________________________
Comments:
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
18 Influence on the project
Which of all the activities from questions 13-17 has the greatest
influence on the quality, maintainability, and extensability of
your project?
o Our way of defining interfaces
o Our decision making strategy
o Our communication culture
o Our specific strengths
o Our specific weaknesses
o Other (please specify):
_______________________________________________
Comments:
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
Thank you very much for your time and good luck for your project!
_______________________________________________
XFree86 mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://XFree86.Org/mailman/listinfo/xfree86