This has been a very long threat and I admit not having read all mails. But I can resist sharing my opinion with you.
LuaTeX and XeTeX use two quite different strategies and therefore address different user communities: the former follows Knuth's philosophy of TeX being independent of other technologies and provides a powerful tool for keeping complete control of typesetting; the latter uses external facilities on the operating system level. The former will be used by courageous people wanting to do any kind of task, from simple to extremely complex; the latter will be used by people wanting a quick and reliable solution to standard problems. Typically, imagine I want to do Arabic with different contextual rules (for any reason). With LuaTeX it is possible, with XeTeX, AFAIK, I cannot be done. But, on the other hand, if there is some beautiful font on my system which I want to use, it is infinitely easier to use it with XeTeX than with any other kind of TeX. But there are also political issues: LuaTeX is developed by a team focusing on ConTeXt. LaTeX users will always be neglected, at least that is the feeling I have (Taco is very kind and helpful but he is paid for a specific task, and LaTeX is not part of it). What about the future? The ideal thing would be to merge them by having two branches of data flow: one that goes through the operating system, one that is handled by Lua. (Something similar happened with OTPs, which from Omega have migrated to LuaTeX, I don't wether they are still there, but at some earlier versions of LuaTeX they were still operational.) The solution is quite artificial but at least the XeTeX part would survive and maybe some day somebody would do a real merge and have Lua control the interaction with the operating system. cheers Yannis -- ------------------------------------------------------- Yannis Haralambous Directeur d'études Institut Mines-Télécom, Télécom Bretagne Département Informatique UMR CNRS 6285 Lab-STICC Technopôle Brest Iroise CS 83818, 29238 Brest Cedex 3, France Tel: +33 2 29 00 14 27 Fax: +33 2 29 00 12 82 Email: yannis.haralamb...@telecom-bretagne.eu Internet: http://omega.enstb.org/yannis ICBM address: 48°21'31.57"N 4°34'16.76"W Twitter: y_haralambous ------------------------------------------------------- ...pour distinguer l'extérieur d'un aquarium, mieux vaut n'être pas poisson ...the ball I threw while playing in the park has not yet reached the ground Es gab eine Zeit, wo ich nur ungern über Schubert sprechen, nur Nächtens den Bäumen und Sternen von ihm vorerzählen mögen.
BEGIN:VCARD VERSION:3.0 N:Haralambous;Yannis;;; FN:Yannis Haralambous ORG:Enseignant-chercheur\, TELECOM Bretagne; EMAIL;type=INTERNET;type=WORK;type=pref:yannis.haralamb...@telecom-bretagne.eu TEL;type=WORK;type=pref:+33 229001427 TEL;type=CELL:+33 607981626 TEL;type=WORK;type=FAX:+33 229001282 item1.ADR;type=WORK;type=pref:;;Département Informatique\, TELECOM Bretagne\, CS 83818;Brest Cedex 3;;29238;France item1.X-ABADR:fr X-ABUID:CD3E6B27-C13F-40A4-B2F7-8393D5CE6493\:ABPerson END:VCARD
-------------------------------------------------- Subscriptions, Archive, and List information, etc.: http://tug.org/mailman/listinfo/xetex
