I have a product that can be built two ways. I have two WiX installer
projects in visual studio, sharing many of the same wxs files. One project
defines a variable in the project settings to cause some of the .wxs files
to compile differently, like this:
...
<Component Id="someFiles" Guid="8909196A-8C89-497c-A850-868D7648F063" >
<File Id="file1" Source="..\..\SharedFiles\File1.exe" KeyPath="yes"
Name="File1.exe">
</File>
<?ifdef IsVersionA ?>
<File Id="File2" Source="..\..\SharedFiles\File2_A.txt"
Name="File2.txt"/>
<?else?>
<File Id="File2" Source="..\..\SharedFiles\File2.txt"
Name="File2.txt"/>
<?endif?>
<File Id="File3" Source="..\..\SharedFiles\File3.txt"
Name="File3.txt"/>
</Component>
<Directory Id="ConfDir" Name="conf">
<Component Id="configFiles"
Guid="936B3B83-AF5D-47ba-9985-3B4D22E6353B">
<?ifdef IsVersionA ?>
<File Id="ConfigFile"
Source="..\..\SharedFiles\conf\server-A.conf" Name="server.conf"/>
<?else?>
<File Id="ConfigFile" Source="..\..\SharedFiles\conf\server.conf"
Name="server.conf"/>
<?endif?>
<File Id="otherConfig" Source="..\..\SharedFiles\etc\"
Name="server-password.conf"/>
</Component>
</Directory>
...
When my project built with "IsVersionA=true" defined in the project settings
"File2.txt" in the msi was a copy of "File2_A.txt" but "server.conf" was a
copy of "..\..\SharedFiles\conf\server.conf" NOT the expected
"..\..\SharedFiles\conf\server-A.conf"
When investigating I manually rebuilt only this project from the solution
(after shuffling some lines around to make File Id="otherConfig" the key
file of Component Id="configFiles") both files were correct. Note that
there is another project in the solution that shares this same .wxs file and
does not define the IsVersionA variable. I thought at the least that if for
some reason the .wxs wasn't being recompiled properly between project builds
when I built the solution (doing a "rebuild") that the results would be
consistent within the single .wxs. They clearly were not - QA reported the
file inconsistency. I double checked to confirm the problem by using orca to
check the file sizes in the .msi. Then I double checked the preprocessor
conditions in the .wxs source file. It was somewhat baffeling.
I'm using an older build of WiX 3 (3.0.2925.0) because the recent builds
don't work well with Visual Studio 2005.
Of course we are noticing this now only a day or two away from when we need
to release the production build... argh!
Can anyone shed some light (hey that's almost a pun) on what might be going
on and how I might deal with it in a reliable way. Getting inconsistent
output from your build tools isn't a good thing.
Thanks,
Scott
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Check out the new SourceForge.net Marketplace.
It's the best place to buy or sell services for
just about anything Open Source.
http://sourceforge.net/services/buy/index.php
_______________________________________________
WiX-users mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/wix-users
