Just passing along an essay I find well written and true albeit two years old.  It is a timely read in light of the AIPAC hate videos Rabbi Glazier, Mitch Knisbacher, and Warren Sanderson showed on Channel 17.  Monica
 
 
Cant and the Middle East
by Sheldon Richman, May 2002

In the world of diplomacy, and politics generally, words are not chosen for their correspondence to the truth. They are chosen for their power to advance some purpose. Thatâs why most of what we hear is cant.

Nowhere is this rule more faithfully observed than in connection with the Middle East.

When President Bush says Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon is a âman of peace,â he doesnât mean that Sharon is a man of peace. He means, rather, that some goal is served by saying Sharon is a man of peaceâeven though he is a man of unfathomable brutality. The events in Jenin are only the latest demonstration of that fact. (He was forced to resign as defense minister in the 1980s after an Israeli commission found him responsible for permitting the massacres of Palestinians by Lebanese allies in southern Lebanon during the Israeli invasion.)

What goal is served by Mr. Bushâs characterization? More than one, no doubt. Clearly it was aimed in part at the neo-conservative wing of his political base, which was disturbed by what sounded like critical utterances against Israel. Although Mr. Bushâs earlier demand of an Israeli withdrawal from the West Bank villages had absolutely no teeth (such as a threat to cut off billions in annual military aid), those who believe that Israel can do no wrong and that the United States should be a good cheerleader were not mollified. Mr. Bush needs the neo-conservatives, and it must have irked him to have them saying that his Middle East policy indicates heâs going âwobblyâ on the âwar on terrorism." When it comes to the Middle East, the last person Mr. Bush wants to be compared with is ... his father.

The president is not the only one who speaks in cant on the Middle East. Ariel Sharon is quite fluent in it too. When he sent his troops into Jenin, he said he would leave âno seed of terror behind." But he surely knows this is nonsense. The destruction of that refugee camp, the murder of Palestinians of all ages, and the delay in allowing access to rescue workers can only sow the seeds of terror, not destroy them. Considering what we know about human nature and the Middle East, it is unlikely that the young people who lived through the onslaught against Jenin will conclude that cooperation with the Israeli government is their most promising course. Their world-view, if anything, has been confirmed by Sharonâs cruelty. Anyone who looks forward to a falling off of Palestinian violence is fooling himself.

But isnât Israel justified by that very violence? Blowing up innocents cannot be condoned. But it is folly to think that that is all one needs to know. Young Palestinian men and women do not kill Israelis because they hate Jews for being Jews. One must blind oneself (and avoid objective historical accounts) to believe there is something inherently irrational about Palestinian animosity toward Israel. After all, Jews and Arabs lived together in Palestine for many years before the twentieth century. As my orthodox grandfather taught me, the relationship between the two communities deteriorated when Judaism was transformed (by secular Jews) into a political movement whose program included encroachment on innocent Arabs in the quest for Greater Israel. (It may come as a surprise, but the harshest critics of Zionism were Reform and Orthodox Jews.) It was the first president of the Hebrew University in Jerusalem, Judah Magnes, who said, âThe slogan âJewish state or commonwealthâ is equivalent, in effect, to a declaration of war by the Jews on the Arabs." In candid moments, Israeli military leaders acknowledged that the land belonged to Arabs.

This will be seen as ancient history, and of course the past cannot be undone. But understanding history is essential to moving intelligently into the future. The Palestinian attacks on innocent civilians must stop. But that goal will have a better chance of realization if the Israeli establishment would give up its dream of a Greater Israel void of Palestinians and really start talking about peaceful coexistence.

Sheldon Richman is senior fellow at The Future of Freedom Foundation in Fairfax, Va., author of âAncient Historyâ: U.S. Conduct in the Middle East since World War II and the Folly of Intervention (Cato Institute), and editor of Ideas on Liberty magazine.

Yahoo! Groups Sponsor
ADVERTISEMENT
click here


Yahoo! Groups Links

Reply via email to