Sharon’s Shell
Game in Rafah
By Starhawk
Just
over a year ago, I sat in a home near the Egyptian border in Rafah, in the Gaza
strip. A five-year-old, curly-haired charmer of a girl was on my lap. Her
older sister and brothers did homework to the background music of the thudding
of bullets into the walls. The children were so inured to gunfire from the
Israeli sniper towers and tanks that they didn’t even react until the gunfire
grew so loud that the older ones dived for the floor, the babies for the fragile
shelter of their mother’s
arms.
I
was there with the International Solidarity Movement, which supports nonviolent
resistance against the Occupation. I’d come to help the teams that were with our
member Rachel Corrie, who was crushed by a soldier in a bulldozer as she
attempted to stop a home demolition, and with Tom Hurndall when he was shot
trying to rescue a group of children who were under fire from an Israeli sniper
tower.
I
think of them, of the families I met and the traumatized children who followed
us in packs whenever we ventured out on the streets, as I read the horrifying
reports of the last weeks in Rafah. The homes I stayed in have been razed to the
ground, along with the crowded neighborhoods where the old men would visit each
other at twilight to brew tea over a small fire and talk, where the women still
baked bread in clay ovens. The olive groves, the orange trees have fallen
to bulldozers. Children like the ones I held and sang to, and their parents,
have been killed in the demonstrations protesting the destruction of their
communities.
To
make the lives of those more hopeful, and to safeguard the lives of Israeli
children, it is vital that we understand the true thrust of Sharon’s current
policies. Sharon is the sleight-of-hand magician, saying ‘Look here!”
while the real action is somewhere else. Sharon says, “Look over here!
We’re pulling out of Gaza!” and Bush says, “OK, and in return, we’ll stop
looking at what you’re doing in the West Bank.” But Gaza and the West Bank are
related, and unless we keep our eyes on both, we’ll be victimized by the shell
game.
Firing
on a crowd of peaceful demonstrators with tank shells and helicopter gunships
was such an outrage that it finally caught the attention of a jaded and cynical
world. But the Israeli military has been responding to nonviolent
demonstrations with extreme violence consistently throughout the past months,
when an upsurge of civil resistance has arisen in the West Bank. This
growing nonviolent movement is focused against the so-called ‘security’ wall
that the military is building, which winds its way deep into Palestinian
territory, confiscating farmland without compensation, scarring the green hills,
uprooting ancient olive trees, and destroying the very communities who have
historically had the most peaceful relationships with their Israeli neighbors.
Those
demonstrations have been supported by internationals from the International
Solidarity Movement, the International Women’s Peace Service, and other human
rights groups. The villagers have also called for help from the Israeli
peace community, and groups as diverse as Rabbis for Human Rights, Bat Shalom,
and Anarchists Against the Wall have responded, along with many others. Standing
together, Palestinians, Israelis and internationals have faced clubs, horses,
and arrests, and been fired on with sound bombs, tear gas, rubber coated steel
bullets, and real bullets. In the village of Biddu alone, five
Palestinians have been shot to death and one has died of tear gas inhalation in
peaceful, unarmed protests. Israelis, too, have been seriously
injured, and many have privately confessed to me that they believe it is only a
matter of time before an Israeli is killed.
The
first intifada, in the late eighties, was primarily a movement of civil
resistance, involving every sector of society in acts of noncompliance with the
occupation, such as boycotts, work stoppages and tax revolts. Among
Palestinians, the first intifada is seen as bringing Israel to the bargaining
table, establishing the PLO as the negotiating voice of the Palestinian
movement, and laying the groundwork for the Oslo peace
accords.
But
the Oslo process is widely seen as one of betrayal. During the decade of
Oslo, Israel continued to fund and support illegal settlements—really armed
suburbs planted on hilltops--in the West Bank and Gaza, doubling the number of
settlers. They confiscated Palestinian land without compensation, built a
network of roads which are off-limits to Palestinians and which divide and
segment their communities, and established a huge military infrastructure to
guard the settlers and staff the checkpoints that restrict Palestinian freedom
of movement.. Disillusionment with Oslo led to disbelief in the Israeli
government’s good faith, and formed the ground for the armed struggle that
characterizes the second intifada.
Only a tiny fraction of
the Palestinian population actively participates in armed resistance. The
vast majority of people want to defend their rights, but don’t want to kill.
A mass movement of civil resistance could provide an avenue for that
struggle and kindle international sympathy and support. A movement in
which Palestinians and Israelis struggle together, side by side, facing the same
clubs and bullets as they have been in these past months, is tremendously
threatening to the power base of the Israeli right wing. So this movement
must be repressed, its leaders arrested, international peace activists denied
entry, and demonstrations brutally repressed. The shooting of demonstrators in
the West Bank sets the stage for the shelling of a demonstration in Gaza and the
deaths of dozens of
Palestinians.
The
West Bank is the goal of Sharon’s aborted Gaza pullout. Gaza has few
resources, was not part of biblical Israel, and contains a large and unruly
Palestinian population who cannot easily be integrated into Israel proper
without threatening the demographics that maintain the thin fiction that Israel
can be both Jewish and democratic, while denying full rights to the twenty
percent of its own citizens who are Palestinian, and keeping those who
live in the territories under martial law for decades.
In the
contest for this region, the West Bank is the prize. It contains some of
the most fertile land, two major aquifers, and regions of still-unspoiled
natural beauty. Most importantly, it is the historic land of the Bible,
where Abraham walked and is buried, where Joshua fought his battle of Jericho,
where the prophets thundered and the festivals were celebrated. The West
Bank was Judea and Samaria, the heart of the promised land.
Trading Gaza for Bush’s tacit agreement to the annexation of the
West Bank looked like a good deal to Sharon. However, he couldn’t sell the
deal to the right wing of his own party, who don’t want to give up an inch or
retreat from so much as an outhouse. So now the military has repaid
assaults on soldiers by massive home demolitions and all-out war on
civilians.
The ‘security’ wall is not a response to suicide
bombings or some escalated condition of danger. It is part of a
long-planned strategy, in place since the 1970s, to expand the state of Israel
into the coveted West Bank lands. One piece of that strategy has
been the building of the illegal settlements’which the wall encloses and, in
effect, annexes along with surrounding farmland, destroying the livelihood of
the neighboring Palestinian farmers. The linked maze of barriers isolates many
Palestinian villages, enclosing them behind barbed wire, cutting them off from
each other and the rest of the West Bank, and turning them into open-air
prisons. The wall and settlements are also linked to the building of
Israel’s transnational highway, which will shift population within Israel proper
to the east, closer to the settlement blocs, so that they can become fully
integrated parts of Israel proper.
The wall confiscates land that
sits atop the major aquifers of the region. Already the settlers, who
comprise less than 10% of the population of the West Bank, use 80% of the water
resources. The wall will take what’s left.
The wall is the
end of any possible Palestinian state. The two-state solution was a reluctant
compromise for many Palestinians, but was adopted and supported by their
leadership and the vast majority of those who live in the Occupied Territories.
It relinquished almost 80% of the historic land of Palestine to Israel, in
return for the promise of an autonomous state on the other 20%. To most
Israelis, it seemed a reasonable solution, and most Palestinians were willing to
accept it, however reluctantly.
With
the construction of the wall, that option is gone. The wall does not leave
enough territory, water or resources to constitute a state. It creates
isolated, open-air prisons out of the Palestinian population
centers.
Whether
you personally favor a two-state, one-state or no-state solution, unilaterally
removing one of the major options for the region is no way to bring about either
peace or security. And if Sharon’s policies remove the option of a
separate state for Palestinians, we must ask what end-game is he planning?
Perpetual occupation, eternal effectual imprisonment for four million people?
Transfer? Outright genocide? These options, elsewhere, are
called ‘ethnic cleansing,’ and none of them are likely to bring about increased
security or peace for Israel or the rest of the world.
A
real policy of security would begin with a moratorium, on Israel’s part, on the
building of the wall, on policies of ‘targeted assassinations’, on attacks on
civilians and brutal responses to nonviolent demonstrations. Such acts
would be a small beginning of a change in course that would demonstrate good
faith and a genuine desire for negotiations in which all people of the region
could have a voice in determining their future.
It is up to those
of us in the US, which funds the Occupation, and the international community to
raise our voices now, to put pressure on Sharon to stop murdering civilians and
children in the name of security, and begin pursuing a true path toward
peace.
For a map of the wall, see:
http://www.gush-shalom.org/thewall/index.html
For
information about the International Solidarity Movement,
see
www.palsolidarity.org <http://www.palsolidarity.org/>
.
Starhawk has
made four trips to the Occupied Terriitories in the last two years with the
International Solidarity Movement. For an archive of her posts and writings
about Palestine, see www.starhawk.org.She <http://www.starhawk.org.She/>
is an activist, organizer, and author of nine published books, including
her latests, Webs of Power: Notes from the Global Uprising and eight
other books on feminism, politics and earth-based spirituality. She
teaches Earth Activist Trainings that combine permaculture design and activist
skills, and works with the RANT trainer’s collective, www.rantcollective.org <http://www.rantcollective.org/>
that offers training and support for mobilizations around global justice
and peace issues.
To get Starhawk’s periodic posts
of her writings, email [EMAIL PROTECTED] and put ‘subscribe’
in the subject heading. If you’re on that list and don’t want any more of
these writings, email [EMAIL PROTECTED] and put
‘unsubscribe’ in the subject heading.
*** NOTICE: In accordance
with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, this material is distributed without profit to
those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information
for research and educational
purposes.***