Has there even been a single P-F DPd electrolysis cell running anywhere in the world in 2013?
When was the last month and year that one was being run? When was the last month and year in which one showed any anomaly? About how much did these runs cost? How carefully were they described in public reports? Are any laboratory components and original records available? The attempts by many groups to replicate the SPAWAR codeposition results with CR39 film recording of claimed particle tracks seem to have floundered in confusion, a few years ago. within the fellowship of service, Rich Murray On Fri, May 10, 2013 at 8:03 PM, Kevin O'Malley <[email protected]> wrote: > On Fri, May 10, 2013 at 3:05 PM, Jed Rothwell <[email protected]>wrote: > To the Japanese in 1941, Americans seemed outlandish. To the skeptics who > agree with Cude or Close, we are the ones disconnected from reality. We are > illogical and even mentally ill thinking that we can "fuse hydrogen in a > mason jar." I do not think it does any good getting angry at such people. > It is important that you understand their mindset. > ***Okay, Jed. What we need as a group is a minimum set of facts that we > agree are incontrovertible. I would think it is that Pons & Fleischmann > were careful electrochemists, the preeminent of their day. That the > physicists who chose to debunk their findings were far from careful due to > inexperience in electrochemistry and this led to their negative findings. > That there have been 14,700 replications of the P-F anomolous heat effect. > If not, then how many? 180, as per Storms and National Instruments? > > What are the base minimum set of facts that we all agree on? > > >> >
