On Sun, Nov 6, 2011 at 6:16 PM, Jed Rothwell <[email protected]> wrote:
> OrionWorks - Steven Vincent Johnson <[email protected]> wrote: > > >> For Krivit to have produced a technically accurate word-for-word >> translation of Rossi's broken English, a typical Rossi-reply which was >> filled with Italian inflections, and pauses, and "umms", and "as" and >> "eh"s, was in my opinion deliberately manipulative. >> > It is worse than that. It is a transparent ploy. It is beneath contempt. > > I have been involved in teaching and learning second languages, and > translation, since I was 16 years old. I have taught dozens of people > English as a second language, and I have edited over a hundred papers in > English by people who speak English as a second language. I spend 20 > minutes a day reading 19th and 20th century literature in Japanese to keep > my edge up, and it is sometimes still a struggle (depending on the book -- > I do not recommend "Wagahai wa neko de aru" the best-seller of 1906). > > In my opinion, Rossi's spoken English is good. Not excellent. It is > perfectly understandable, and better than many other Italian researchers I > know. The point is, he is an engineer, not a writer, translator or > television personality. His English skills are good enough for his > purposes. He has clearly devoted a lot of effort and time to mastering > English. The U.S. is a mono-lingual society, unlike Europe. Very few > native-born Americans speak a second language as well as Rossi does. I > doubt that Krivit does. I doubt he has any idea how difficult it is, or how > well Rossi is doing it. > > In essence Krivit is making fun of a foreign accent. He is saying that a > foreign accent is evidence of deception or low intelligence. Many people > believed that in the 19th century. It is shocking that anyone still thinks > this way in the 21st century. People use to say that about minority group > dialects in the U.S., such as Appalachian ones -- commonly known as > "hillbilly" accents. Needless to say, people also denigrated black > dialects, Irish and others. Up the 1930s some native American children were > forced into schools where English was the only language allowed, and they > were beaten if they spoke their native language. Even today, some Americans > take speech therapy to rid themselves of regional accents. From my point of > view this is like tearing down ancient cathedrals to erect fast-food > joints. It is a crime against linguistic diversity. > > I wish our society was beyond that, but there are still throwbacks such as > Krivit, who appeal to our worst instincts and base prejudice. > > - Jed > > I am really far from being a Rossi-fan but this is a kitschy trick, irrelevant and inefficient, and the natural reaction is contrary to that expected by the reporter. -- Dr. Peter Gluck Cluj, Romania http://egooutpeters.blogspot.com

