Okay, Lewan told me that after the run there was at least 20 L of hot water
left in the vessel. He did not measure it the way he did after the September
test, but the vessel was pretty full.

If there was any water let in the vessel that proves there must have been
some cooling water flowing into it during the test. If the water was going
out at the rate of 0.9 g/s (3.2 L/h), and there was no input, the vessel
would have been nearly empty after nine hours. There would have been less
than 1 L left.

I think it is much more likely the average flow rate out was close to the
incoming rate, and both were ~4 g/s.

Lewan mentioned there was also a leak, which has been discussed here. Some
amount of water left the cell via the leak. The important thing is, the
replacement water coming in was at tap water temperature. It was coming in
from the large plastic trashcan.

The flow rate also had to be high enough so that people  could see water
moving to the pipe. I expect it was closer to 4 g/s than 0.9 g/s, most of
the time.

This proves the water was cooled down with incoming tap water. Obviously it
also radiated a lot of heat. These two facts together prove that it could
not have remained at the same temperature for four hours without a source of
power inside the cell.

It would be much better if we had a detailed record of the amount of water
that was pumped into the cell, with a precision flowmeter between the pump
and the cell.

It would be difficult to determine how much of the water left via the of the
leak and how much was vaporized or overflowed and ended up going through the
heat exchanger. I suppose you could put another precision flowmeter below
the heat exchanger, but even a high precision meter would have difficulty
measuring this.

To determine how much cooling water displaced the original water in the
cell, you do not need to know whether the outflow left via the leak or via
the heat exchanger.

By the way, if there was no water flowing into the cell, that would mean
there must have been intense anomalous heat. Otherwise, the cell would have
radiated enough to cool down, and it would soon stop boiling. After that,
the water would not have gone from the cell into the heat exchanger. Without
a flow of incoming water to displace the existing water, boiling is the only
thing that can force it into the heat exchanger.

If there had been no flow, and no boiling to push the water into the
exchanger, the exchanger would have dropped to room temperature very
quickly. It would have done this in the time it takes that much metal to
cool down, maybe 10 minutes, It would have registered no Delta T. Even if
the reactor vessel had remained hot, cooling only by radiation and not by
displaced hot water, none of that heat would have reached the exchanger.

- Jed

Reply via email to