First, you hit a sore point here, and I'm going to address it first. The sore point is people giving some special, unusual meaning to a common word, and then pretending that they've done something more clever than just introduce a monkey wrench into the discussion.

On 11-09-23 07:32 PM, Mauro Lacy wrote:
I'll probably tell you too that for me science, real science, is about knowledge of the way things really are.

Wrong on the face of it. Language is for communication, and communication using language requires a previously agreed to set of meanings for the words to be used. Consequently, you are welcome to define some word to mean "knowledge of the way things /really/ are", along with your own personal definition of the term "really are", but the word for that isn't science, which has rather more limited goals.

You can pretend that "/real/ science" would have a more broad reaching goal than what "/ordinary/ science" has, but "science" is just a word, words are just for communication, and to have value in communication the word must be vested with its commonly accepted meaning. By definition, a word means what it is commonly agreed to mean -- nothing more and nothing less.

If you use a word to mean something other than that, then you are using it for obfuscation, not communication.

"Science", as the word is commonly used, refers to a particular technique and the knowledge which has been gained by that technique. The (extremely simple) technique of "science" consists of observing reality, making guesses about what makes it all go, and then /testing/ the guesses. The knowledge which has been gained by applying that technique is the aggregate of the guesses which have been made, and the results of the tests which have been applied, and really, that's all there is to it.

Anything else is outside the realm of "science", as the word is commonly used. In particular, determining the nature of some unknown and ultimately untestable "absolute reality" is utterly beyond its scope.


On 11-09-23 07:32 PM, Mauro Lacy wrote:
[ ... ]
Now, looking at the picture again, I can ask you: what is moving in the galaxy? In general, you'll answer that stars, dust clouds, etc. are moving, and that their movement has taken a spiral form, again, due to gravity and due to a given initial rotation of the system, which was in the past a giant dust cloud of some kind(which was rotating who knows why), and gradually developed stars and planets out of the initial irregularities.

And then I'll ask you: the empty space between stars, planets, etc. which is in the galaxy, is also moving? You'll probably answer that, given our current understanding of the matter, only matter can move, not empty space. Moreover, you'll cite scientific premises like Occam's razor and the like, to announce that we shouldn't multiply the entities, that only observables and measurable things must be considered, etc.

No, I won't invoke Occam's Razor at all.

I'll merely point out that we can easily cast your comments about the motion of space itself in classical terms. You are talking about an "aether", and a sort of "reverse aether drag" where the moving aether drags the stars along.

To date, the aether theories which are consistent with experimental results are also consistent with the predictions of SR, which is purely geometric and does not require an aether. Consequently, to date there's no evidence for the existence of an aether. But that could change tomorrow.

If the motion of the stars in spiral galaxies can be explained by an aether theory, then obviously that would change things rather a lot -- and the aether would move from the realm of speculation (which is what an untestable theory is) and into the realm of theories producing testable predictions. But to get to that point, you'd need to refine your speculation enough to explain not just precisely what the interaction between the aether and the stars is, but you would also need to explain what was making the aether whirl around like that. If you can't come up with a solid reason for the latter, then you've got no constraints on how you can assume the aether moves, and your theory starts looking untestable.

It is not Occam's Razor that says that any theory which produces no testable predictions is not a valid theory. Rather, it's the basic principle of science: You observe, you guess, and you /test your guess/. If you can't test your guess in any way, then it's a useless sort of guess.



And then I'll answer that it strikes me as completely self evident that what has caused the beautiful spiral arrangement of the stars in the galaxy arms is the movement of space itself.

As I said, quantify that, so that it makes a testable prediction, and it becomes an interesting theory.

Absent such quantification, it's just speculation, and is outside the realm of science, which doesn't deal with things which cannot be tested.


Reply via email to