thomas malloy wrote:

Correct me if I'm wrong, but in the previous discussions we have had about this matter, the strength of materials will have to increase by more than an order of magnitude in order to make the ribbon possible.

I do not know where it stands today. Edwards & Westling's book is from 2003. They point out, however, that you could make an orbital tower out of bubblegum if you made the base wide enough; I think it was roughly as wide as the U.S. So the question is not whether the ribbon is possible, but whether it is practical; i.e. narrow enough at the base to be lifted up into space, and reasonably inexpensive.

Page 21 - 25 describes "Status of Carbon Nanotube Development." Some interesting points:

The theoretical limit to nanotube strength is around 300 gigapascals (GPa). That can hold 3,000,000 kg of a cable cross-section only 1 cm wide. "Or to put it even closer to home you could lift a large car with a nanotube cable the size of an ordinary sewing thread."

Steel strength is 4.2 gig pascals; Kevlar is 3.6 GPa. "The density of carbon nanotubes (1.3 g/cm3) is not only lower than steel (7.9 g/cm3) but also lower than its close cousins Kevlar (1.44 g/cm3) and graphite whiskers (2.0 g/cm3)."

Strength and density together determine the cross-section of the cable at the earth end. That is, the taper.

Regarding actual results, Yu et al. (2000) measured nanotube strength varying from 11.2 to 64.3 GPa. But they made only small samples.

- Jed

Reply via email to